TVA swaps away nearly 600 lakefront acres to developer
John “Thunder” Thornton, a University of Tennessee trustee, booster and political contributor, plans to build a $450 million gated community with up to 1,100 luxury homes, a golf course and boat slips on Nickajack Lake.
He is turning over to TVA three other nearby parcels — 615-acre Little Cedar Mountain, a 260-acre farm and 220-acre Burns Island.
About a half-dozen American Indians who consider the land Thornton is getting sacred and historic protested at the auction, which was held on the property about 30 miles west of Chattanooga.
Banners stretched between trees read, “Eminent domain. Stolen land. End TVA land theft for profits” and “TVA — stop the land rape! TVA duty — protect the land.”
“I understand their viewpoint,” said Thornton, who attended the auction. “I am a conservationist…. I want to develop property in the right way.”
Corky Allen of Chattanooga, president of the Intratribal Sacred Land Trust, said TVA failed to properly include American Indian heritage groups in the decision-making. He said Indians are considering a lawsuit to stop the development.
Spencer Boardman, TVA’s manager for watershed operations and special projects, said the utility “consulted with the Native Americans and fulfilled all our obligations.”
Tom Kunesh of the Sacred Little Cedar Mountain Defense Coalition has said there are “significant Native American remains” on the land.
Thornton said he has been focused on protecting Indian artifacts and the environment. An archaeological study that he funded showed the island he swapped to TVA to be much more historically valuable than the 578-acre tract.
The Tennessee Wildlife Federation, the Tennessee River Gorge Trust supported the swap, due partly to the 2-for-1 acreage return for TVA. Gov. Phil Bredesen urged TVA to approve the swap in a May 2005 letter, months after his campaign account received $2,500 from Thornton.
Thornton, whose $1 million donation to University of Tennessee athletic programs won him the opportunity to run into Neyland Stadium with the football team one game day, said construction would begin shortly after the transaction closes in 120 days and will create about 150 permanent jobs.
Lots will sell for between $60,000 and several hundred thousand dollars, he said.
Marion County school superintendent Fred Taylor supported the deal.
“It basically doubles the property value of the county,” Taylor said, and could mean as much as an additional $4 million annually for schools.
“That doesn’t include the sales tax,” he said.
To close the deal, Thornton’s Nickajack Shores LLC development group must pay TVA $7.2 million to cover fair market value, mitigation fees and the federal utility’s administrative costs.
TVA officials said the only other potential bidder for the property did not meet requirements.
TVA, which supplies electricity to 8.5 million residential customers in Tennessee and parts of Alabama, Mississippi, Kentucky, Georgia, North Carolina and Virginia, owns more than 200,000 acres of shoreline along the Tennessee River system — much of it acquired using eminent domain powers.
John E. Webb of Gainesville, Ga., whose father was forced to sell his 110-acre Tennessee River farm for the building of Nickajack Lake, declined comment about the auction, saying it wouldn’t do any good.
“With the simple stroke of a pen, my father’s farm was gone, completely against his will,” Webb said in an October letter to TVA opposing the land swap.
