Americans quick to judge Arabs
The bipartisan uproar over a Middle East company’s management of U.S. port facilities demonstrates how steeped American politicians are in Arabophobia.
Before they knew anything about the company, Dubai Ports World, or about security responsibilities at U.S. ports, Republicans and Democrats in Congress and affected states shouted a “No!” that has implications far beyond the case at hand.
Domestically, it shows how politically weak President Bush has become that GOP leaders like Senate Majority Leader Bill Frist (Tenn.) and Speaker Dennis Hastert (Ill.) leaped to distance themselves from Bush on the port incident.
That’s surely the result of setbacks ranging from continuing troubles in Iraq to continuing discord over National Security Agency terrorist surveillance to unfavorable Hurricane Katrina post-mortems to the flap over Vice President Cheney’s tardy reporting of his hunting accident.
It’s true that the Bush administration was politically tone-deaf in failing to realize that an Arab firm’s takeover of operations at six U.S. ports could be politically radioactive.
In a reaction more befitting a talk show host than a member of Congress, Rep. Sue Myrick, R-N.C., posted a letter to Bush on a right-wing Web site reading “Dear Mr. President: In regards to selling American ports to the United Arab Emirates, not just NO but HELL NO!”
The media has played its part by leaving the impression that Dubai World Ports would “own” U.S. ports. Actually, the company would own the company that loads and off-loads cargo at ports that are publicly owned.
Bush complicated the political situation by threatening to veto any legislation blocking or delaying the transfer, which played into his reputation of “disdain for outside views in general and congressional views in particular,” as Democratic Sen. Carl Levin (Mich.) put it.
Senate Armed Services Chairman John Warner, R-Va., did rationality a service by calling an immediate hearing on the transfer, at which representatives of the State, Defense and Treasury departments defended their decision.
On the negative side, it’s true that two of the Sept. 11, 2001, hijackers were citizens of the United Arab Emirates, that UAE banks allowed Al-Qaeda funds to be transferred internationally, and that UAE ports served as a transit point for illicit nuclear materials.
However, since Sept. 11, UAE has become what Warner called a “stalwart” U.S. ally that has cracked down on terrorist financing and nuclear proliferation and serves as the largest single base for U.S. warships outside the United States.
A close Congressional look at the port deal might turn up evidence of security dangers, but so far experts say that it will in no way affect the responsibilities of the Coast Guard, Customs Service or pre-cleared U.S. port workers.
The flap also may result in needed upgrades in U.S. port security, which is apparently better than often portrayed by critics, but still needs more funding than it gets.
Enemies of the United States are using every means to fuel violent enmity between the West and the Muslim world. It’s what the worldwide cartoon riots were all about and outrageous charges by Iran’s president that the United States and Israel were behind the bombing of one of Shia Islam’s holiest shrines in Iraq.
Democrats, in particular, constantly say that the United States should rely on “soft power” — diplomacy, trade and cultural relations — rather than military force to expand American influence. Blocking the port deal would certainly undermine that power.
This is a moment of truth for the United States. Can its leaders overcome prejudices and petty politics to make a rational judgment? Or will small-mindedness help America’s mortal enemies?
Morton Kondracke is executive editor of Roll Call, the newspaper of Capitol Hill.
