Controversy surrounds new subdivision-Residents upset housing project allowed next to $100,000 homes
|
McMinnville Regional Planning Commission members rejected the final plans for the $4.7 million development when problems were presented to them by city planner David Baird.
‘There are numerous problems with the plat and the contractor has been contacted numerous times about making the necessary changes and they have failed to do so,’ Baird said.
Some of the problems presented included the lack of an evergreen tree buffer in the final drawings, submitting DeKalb County forms in lieu of the city’s, using more than one sheet of paper for information, and no park in the final drawings.
As explained, the final paperwork and drawings are required to be exact in order for the Planning Commission to make sure the development is within code restrictions. If the final papers and drawings do not remove any doubt, as these did not, the plans are denied.
Numerous residents in the area around Quail Run, which is low-income housing, were happy to hear the plans were denied. However, their happiness was short lived. Once the development meets all code requirements, the city’s hands are tied and the project will be approved.
Because the city can only enforce codes, area residents will have to seek legal advice when it comes to restricting what is built on the property by that property owner.
For the residents who now live in Falcon Place, where the subdivision will be attached, the news that the city can’t stop the development isn’t welcome.
‘Back when my wife and I were looking for a house, we looked at Falcon Place and talked to Mr. (Donald) Hillis. Houses were $100,000 plus and there were restrictions. What happened to that’? asked Jason Rankhorn. His wife, Sarah, presented the commission with a petition to stop the development signed by over 100 residents.
The original subdivision, Falcon Place, was constructed by Hillis with intentions of adding on a second phase with the same type of development. However, he sold the land with no building restrictions in the deed.
‘Katherine Bryant promised me she was going to develop it just as I did the front part,’ said Hillis. ‘Now somewhere between there and this, this is what happened. If I had known this would happen, I would have added the restriction to the deed.’
Without restrictions, something other than single-family homes can be built on R-2 zoned land. In this case, it’s 14 duplexes and 22 single homes with eligibility based on income.
The deed situation could lead to a legal battle between Quad States Construction, which is behind the project, and area residents concerning what the property owner builds and what the residents were told. As pointed out by Ron Neale, ‘When you start putting a housing project behind them, I think they have legal grounds to stand on.’
The next Planning Commission meeting is scheduled for July 7 at 5 p.m. If the developer has all the required paperwork in order, commission members will have no choice but to allow the development to begin. If they deny it at that point, the city and commission members could face legal action of their own.
After the Planning Commission adjourned, Hillis encouraged the homeowners to immediately contact an attorney to get a legal opinion. Although they can attend the next meeting, that will not stop the development and waiting may leave them behind the eight ball.

