Neal says his cousin had no idea he was stealing metal
The cousin of a man accused of helping steal over 700 pounds of metal from the county highway department says he was an innocent party whose only mistake was helping him load the steel to take to a scrap yard.
‘His only involvement was helping his cousin,’ testified Josh Neal in the case against his cousin, Michael Shane Davis, who has been in jail for nearly a month since their arrests. ‘I’ve been trying to get him out of this since day one.’
Lawmen say Neal, along with Davis and Neal’s fianc??, Amber Nichols, stole at least 740 pounds of guard rail material from outside the county road garage off Old Smithville Highway. They are each charged with multiple counts of theft over $500.
According to sheriff’s investigator Jim Hartman, Neal sold the metal on two occasions to South Central Iron and Metal, one shipment of 620 pounds which brought $52, and a second load of 120 pounds which brought $10. The metal itself was valued at around $800. However, the alleged thieves were only paid scrap prices.
The three reportedly made two visits to the metal pile which was located in a small field outside the county road department building. On the second visit, Hartman said they were confronted by an employee who told them they were taking county property, prompting them to put back most of the metal with exception of the 120 pounds which was sold the second time.
While admitting they took the metal, Neal maintained he thought the metal was free since it was lying in an overgrown field rusting. Neal said it had been lying there for years and that he asked his cousin to help load the metal, thinking himself that it was merely scrap no one wanted.
‘We thought it was free,’ Neal testified.
However, Hartman said while Neal may be telling the truth about his first visit, the fact he sold metal from the second visit after being told who owned the metal would indicate he was stealing.
‘His not knowing it belonged to somebody may have been true, that is until the second trip,’ said Hartman, telling Davis’ attorney, assistant public defender Trenena Wilcher, that 120 pounds is not something someone accidentally steals, pointing out the second load was basically her body weight. ‘I’d say 120 pounds would be about your size.’
Neal countered that there was other metal he had collected elsewhere included in the second sale, noting he found just three metal plates weighing about 30 pounds total in the bed of his truck when he unloaded the second load of scrap.
Regardless, Neal said his cousin was simply trying to help him move the metal and had no way of knowing the metal was stolen.
While sending the case on to the grand jury against all three suspects, General Sessions Judge Larry Ross cut Davis’ bond to $1,000 so he can get out while awaiting trial should he be indicted.
