Officials mixed on cutting non-profit funds-Rutherford has presented idea as way for city to change course
Are they in, or are they out?
With 2008-09 city budget talks just weeks away, one issue that promises to command attention is whether McMinnville city government continues to fund non-profit organizations.
During past budget talks, city officials have agonized over funding requests from non-profits. In most discussions, there have been questions about which non-profits to fund, how much to give each one, if any organization should be cut, and if new requests should be considered.
Although the final results of those discussions have changed from year to year, the process has remained unchanged. In last year’s donations, the city gave $42,412 to social services consisting of 10 organizations, $96,650 to the Industrial Development Board, and $50,000 to Main Street McMinnville.
Aldermen don’t appear eager to remove that funding from the budget.
‘I guess it depends on what the overall budget looks like,’ said Finance Committee chairperson Patti Nunley. ‘If it looks like we are going to have a shortfall, which we very well could given the economic situation, something will need to be cut.’
If cuts need to be made, an effort will be made to make those cuts in other areas. In the event non-profits must be cut, Nunley would be for cutting the funding in stages and not all at once.
When it comes to Alderman Donald Hillis, he says non-profits will not be cut. However, they will have to show how they benefit city residents.
‘It’s not going to be cut out,’ Hillis said. ‘This year, we want a progress report on what you did with the funding and how it benefited city taxpayers.’
In January, city administrator David Rutherford asked officials to consider changing course.
Instead of doing the same thing year after year ‘ and hoping for different results ‘ Rutherford wants to try something different in order to change the result.
Rutherford asked city aldermen to consider diverting the funds awarded to non-profits, the IDB, and Main Street McMinnville and using that money to hire two companies ‘ one would reportedly bring in new businesses, and the other would battle community negativity.
At a cost of $70,000, Buxton Identifying Customers out of Texas, will identify three geographic locations or specific sites and a list of 20 contacts for businesses that might be interested in those sites. Also, the city will receive the site and customer information to draw in new businesses on its own.
The negative economic outlook held by the community, Rutherford say, won’t help bring in new business. A public relations company would answer two questions: 1) Why is the community so negative? 2) How do we train ourselves to project a positive attitude to people who visit the community?
Rutherford also asked officials to take a look at the other contributions ‘ emergency management, rescue squad, library, Upper Cumberland Development District, Chamber of Commerce and Sister Cities ‘ totaling $88,540.
‘I think it is not the best position for us to be in where we take tax dollars, when people pay their taxes, and then the board sits down and decides which group gets money,’ he said.
At that time, officials were asked if they wanted to continue with things as they are or go in a different direction. However, no final decision was made.
So far this year, the city has received requests for funding in the 2008-09 budget from some non-profits, including Main Street McMinnville, the IDB, Senior Center, and Meals on Wheels.
When the budget is presented to officials in the upcoming weeks, they will have to decide if non-profit organizations are in or out when it comes to contributions. The budget will be in the hands of the Finance Committee first.
