Employers who hire legal foreign help deserve praise
TO THE EDITOR:
We here at Frank Basham Nursery would like to set the record straight regarding the statement by Ms. Melody Fowler-Green in the article in Sunday’s Southern Standard about local nurserymen who participate in the H2-A program.
It may very well be that Ms. Green has talked to hundreds of H2-A workers at dozens of employers in the area, and it may be true that virtually every one of them has complaints, and also, that 95 percent of them are too afraid to complain.
However, I would imagine if Ms. Green had spoken to hundreds of non-H2-A workers in the area, she would have encountered similar results.
Frank Basham Nursery has been blessed to have been able to contract the same four H2-A workers, every year, for the past 10 years. These men are dedicated to their jobs, clock-in and out punctually and never grumble or complain. They are outside eight to 10 hours every day in the freezing cold weather of February and in the sweltering heat of August and they are grateful to be here.
Please allow me to fill in some of the facts that were omitted from the above mentioned article:
The headline of the article is, to say the least, misleading.
To quote from the dictionary, an immigrant is: ‘One who immigrates; one who comes to a country for the purpose of permanent residence.’ An H2-A worker is not an immigrant, but a person who has a temporary work contract with a specific employer for a specific time period and for a specific job at a pre-determined, although not fixed, rate of pay. When the contract is complete, the H2-A worker must, by law, return to his/her country of citizenship.
The H2-A process is a complicated and expensive one for the employer.
When an employer determines how many workers he will need for the following year, he fills out a stack of papers an inch thick and pays hundreds of dollars to the H2-A recruiter to begin the contract process. If the contract is approved, the employer must pay for the travel expenses for each worker to the place of employment and also their return trip home. While the H2-A worker is employed, the employer must furnish specified housing which must be inspected by a government official prior to the worker’s arrival. The employer must pay for this housing and all utilities, furnish transportation to a grocery store once a week and also provide Worker’s Compensation Insurance.
An H2-A worker does not pay any taxes yet, their rate of pay is increased by our government annually. This year it went from $8.65 per hour to $9.13 and is $3.28 more per hour than the required $5.85 minimum wage for a U.S. citizen which, by the way, is only .15 cents more than the minimum wage in Mexico for the same job (2006 figures).
In return for his effort and expense, the employer is guaranteed a contract with people who are committed to doing the required work. Our H2-A employees leave their friends and families in Mexico for 10 months at a time and they are here for one reason only and that is to work. In my three years here, only one of our four workers has ever missed one day of work, and that was because he fell while holding a knife, nearly severed his finger and required $6,000 worth of emergency surgery which was covered by Worker’s Comp.
I have only three-and-a-half years experience in the nursery business and in that time I have learned the H2-A program is a ball of confusion for the employer who attempts to adhere to the rules. Ask the same question of three different officials and you will get three different answers, if you’re lucky enough to get an answer.
I finish by saying that any employer who attempts to legally hire foreign farm workers should be praised, not condemned, and if there is a discrepancy in following the rules, the fault lies with the system that created them and not the employer.
Sincerely,
Sandy Stubblefield
Frank Basham Nursery
Viola
