Skip to content

Dog abuse charge upgraded to felony-Barnett faces up to 6 years

Dog abuse charge upgraded to felony-Barnett faces up to 6 years

BARNETT
The Morrison man arrested in a local animal abuse case in which a dog’s teeth were filed down, generating national attention and outrage from animal advocates, will now be facing a felony charge.

Christopher Lee Barnett, 35, was originally charged with cruelty to animals, a misdemeanor for the first offense. After further investigation, local prosecutors upgraded the charges to aggravated cruelty to animals, a Class E felony.

Barnett was issued a warrant on the new charges last week. The maximum sentence on misdemeanor cruelty to animals is 11 months, 29 days in the county jail and a fine of up to $2,500. The felony charge has a range of one to six years and a fine of up to $3,000.

Barnett’s charges stem from his treatment of an Alaskan Husky named Lucas, one of two dogs in his possession. Barnett, a farrier by trade, was observed beating the dog on more than one occasion by a neighbor, Vincent Maxwell, and some of his employees.

When confronted about the beatings Maxwell says Barnett told him the dog had chewed some wiring under his home, but wouldn’t do it anymore because he had filed the dog’s teeth down.

Maxwell was concerned about the situation and got in contact with Warren County Humane Society president Andy Anderson, who advised him to swear out a warrant. Maxwell did so and Barnett was subsequently arrested.

The story, which was covered by local and state media, has caused a furor among animal advocates across the country, even generating an online petition to have the charges upgraded, which has so far received over 2,200 signatures.

Both Lucas and the other dog owned by Barnett were removed and placed in the care of the Humane Society.

While some advocates have implied authorities here did not take the case seriously, due to the original misdemeanor charge, local assistant district attorney Joshua Crain says that is not the case.

‘I think what lot of people don’t understand about the process is that it was not the District Attorney’s office that took the original charge,’ Crain said. ‘The original charge was taken by a private citizen.’

Crain said he did not learn of the charge until he went to court to handle the arraignment, noting the local judicial commissioner who issued the original warrant did so based on the information available at that point.

Crain said Anderson and other Humane Society members had conferred with him and were concerned on whether there was enough evidence to support a felony charge, but everyone, including District Attorney Lisa Zavogiannis, agreed it warranted further investigation.

‘Once we got photographs, statements from other individuals, and once I conducted interviews with people who are going to be crucial to the case,’ Crain said, ‘it became apparent to the district attorney and myself that we could in fact justify a felony case from a legal standpoint, not just an emotional standpoint. So we made the decision to issue the felony warrant.’

According to Crain, Barnett will go before General Sessions Court on April 1 on the new felony charge, at which point he can opt to bind the matter directly to the grand jury or request a preliminary hearing before Judge Larry Ross. Either decision will eventually lead to the grand jury.

Crain says one disconcerting aspect is the numerous calls and letters questioning why the felony charge wasn’t issued in the beginning.

‘It was assumed we didn’t look at this thing as a serious crime, but that wasn’t accurate,’ Crain said. ‘It was taken very seriously by this office from the day that man was arraigned.’

Crain said the Humane Society, which had also received some criticism, was initially concerned if there was not enough evidence to support a felony charge the case might fail in court and Barnett might actually get his dogs back.

‘That’s what we were worried about,’ said Anderson. ‘We wanted to make sure the charges would stick. There’s no way we want that man to get these dogs back.’

Anderson says if there is a bright side to this story it’s the support and funds the Humane Society has received for Lucas’ care and medical treatment. Dr. Samuel L. Young, DVM, a local vet, performed the dental work, which was extensive.

‘He extracted a total of seven teeth because they were so splintered and damaged below the gum line that they couldn’t be saved,’ Anderson said. ‘Then he had to do 16 nerve root canals and fill those teeth.

‘But all his dental work is now done,’ Anderson continued. ‘All we have to do now is wait for his gums to heal up, which could take from 10 to 12 days, and if his gums get well by that time he’ll be able to eat regular dog food.’

Anderson says, thanks to Dr. Young, Lucas should live a normal life despite the horrendous abuse he suffered at the hands of his owner.

‘Thankfully he won’t be badly impaired,’ Anderson said. ‘He should be able to eat like any other dog.’

Leave a Comment