Skip to content

New historic guideline proposals create several concerns

Replacing the current Historic Zoning Commission manual with the one recently generated by the Historic Ad Hoc Committee might be easier said than done ‘ at least until a few changes have been made.

There have been some concerns expressed regarding the new manual currently under consideration.

The area of most concern pertains to the procedure for obtaining a Certificate of Appropriateness before changes to a downtown building can be done.

According to the current manual, all changes to the outside of a historic building within a Historic District must be taken before the Historic Zoning Commission for their consideration. If the work is acceptable, a COA is given. Those not satisfied with their ruling can appeal to the Board of Mayor and Aldermen.

By the new manual generated by the Historic Ad Hoc Committee, those wanting a COA would go to Planning and Zoning for approval. If denied, they could go before the Historic Zoning Commission and then the board.

According to the Tennessee Historical Commission, a COA can only be given by the Historic Zoning Commission and the procedure cannot be changed.

Before the board has its first look at the new manual, the change back to the previous procedure will be made. At that time other changes can be considered, like those suggested at the public hearing Feb. 26.

During the public hearing, Main Street director Chris Wilson voiced his concerns that the new manual may be detrimental to the development of upper-story residential uses in downtown buildings and unclear in other areas.

Within the new manual, under doors, entrances and storefronts, original storefront configurations shall be preserved. This requirement does not allow buildings to be altered to allow access to upper stories from the street. Without street-level access to upper floors, use is limited.

Rather, the manual could say ‘with the exception of adding an entrance door to one side of the storefront to the upper story from the street as long as it does not alter the overall configuration and is compatible with the existing storefront in terms of materials and style.’

‘I know several property owners who are interested in doing this to their storefronts in order to add residential to the upper story,’ said Wilson.

Allowing this to remain affects the property owner and the potential resident. It also has an effect on obtaining a PILOT tax freeze from the McMinnville Downtown Revenue Finance Corporation because obtaining a COA is a key part of the application process.

Another area, unrelated to uses, that may pose future problems is with awnings. The new guidelines addresses replacement awnings by stating they shall be designed to fit the openings used as a storefront.

‘But you do not have the same guidelines for new or the addition of awnings,’ said Wilson. ‘Don’t you want the same guidelines for both? Recommendations might also discourage wood as a material too.’

Lastly, the sign guideline states the maximum area of any sign located in the historic district, with the exception of the Park Theater, shall be 16 square feet.

Wilson questioned, ‘This would be one sign, measuring no more than 16 square feet, correct? This does not mean any amount of smaller signage that measures up to 16 square feet total, correct? Does this also mean that an owner has to choose between a hanging sign and a flat sign on the facade?

‘Also, does this mean that attorneys cannot have more than one sign on their facade designating if there is more than one attorney in the same office location? Is this true for an office or retail suite? I just want to be sure of the guidelines.’

Leave a Comment