Michael Martin outraged by pay disparities for county officials
A pair of resolutions presented by Commissioner Michael Martin at the February County Commission meeting, one to prohibit pay raises for county employees except during yearly budget preparation, and the other to set the meeting fees for the Warren County Planning Commission, are generating some controversy because they did not move through the regular committee process.
Neither resolution was included in the monthly packet and therefore required a majority vote to be added to the docket. Both ultimately failed to get approval, though for different reasons. With 22 commissioners present, the resolution on pay raises brought about an 11-11 tie, and thus failed to receive the majority vote needed to be added to the docket.
The resolution on establishing the meeting fees for the Planning Commission would have reduced the fee from the current $100 per meeting to $15, the same as commissioners receive for each meeting they attend. This resolution was appended to the docket with a vote of 13-9, but during discussion Commissioner Carl Bouldin made a motion to table the resolution for further study.
This motion drew an 11-11 tie vote, and would have failed for lack of a majority. But in a move that would draw criticism from Martin later, County Executive John Pelham, who as chairman of the commission is allowed to break ties under certain circumstances, voted to table the resolution, breaking the 11-11 stalemate and delaying action on the issue until the March meeting.
The resolution on the Planning Commission fees was due to longtime issues Martin has had with the disparity in fees between some of the various commissions and boards and those paid to commissioners.
Martin’s resolution regarding the salary increases reportedly grew out a Budget and Finance Committee meeting early this year where General Sessions Judge Larry Ross requested permission to provide mid-fiscal-year raises for his office personnel. The funds would have come from the remaining salary of a longtime employee who had left his office.
Ross pointed out the money was already in his budget, but Martin disagreed with this use of the funds, leading to a minor altercation between the two.
Since Budget and Finance consisted of only four members at the time, due to chairman George Smartt stepping down to run for the state Senate appointment, Ross’ request failed for lack of a majority, with Ken Martin and Herschel Wells voting for the move, while Michael Martin and Terry Bell voted against.
But even though the original resolutions received no action at the February meeting, the situations that generated them are still open to discussion, which was demonstrated at a recent meeting of the Policy and Personnel Committee.
At the meeting, Commissioner Bill Yancy provided a list of those fees, which indicated members of some governmental bodies, like the E-911 Board and the Airport Commission, receive no fees, while members of others, such as the Planning Commission at $100, the Election Commission at $150 per month and $55 per meeting, and the Equalization Board at $60 per day, receive considerably more than the standard $15 paid to commissioners.
Yancy said he agreed with Michael on the Planning Commission fees.
‘My thoughts on the matter are that $100 per meeting is excessive,’ Yancy said. ‘If we can live with $15, they ought to be able to live with $15. Their gas doesn’t cost them any more, and I don’t think their time is any more valuable than mine. I think the fees should be equal for everyone.’
However, Yancy had a different view on the salary increases.
‘I don’t think I have the right to tell Judge Ross how to run his office,’ Yancy said. ‘And the money was already in his budget, so I feel a little differently on that one.’
In the end, the committee voted unanimously to move the issues on to the Budget and Finance Committee for further discussion.
