Skip to content

Rutherford asks aldermen for annexation stance

Will McMinnville officials move forward to annex land despite disapproval from property owners, or will they once again back down?

City administrator David Rutherford asked Finance Committee members for direction on what they want to do when it comes to annexation in three areas that were discussed during last year’s planning conference. Property owners have already voiced their disapproval for annexation in one of the areas discussed.

‘Do you want to move forward with advertising, notifying property owners, putting plans and services together, and then when people show up, we drop the ball,’ asked Rutherford.

Although Rutherford hasn’t been around long, he has been around long enough to see a pattern of discussing annexation, and taking the necessary steps for it. This is followed by property owners voicing their disapproval, and city officials backing off.

The question of annexation comes after McMinnville city planner David Baird recommended the following areas for annexation to the McMinnville Regional Planning Commission in January:

‘ Newtown ‘ South side of Highway 70S from H.T. Pelham Memorial Parkway to behind South Circle. As well as the north side of Highway 70S, tracts currently adjacent to the left and right side of Bridge Builders Road.

‘ Smithville Highway ‘ Two small parcels, five acres, in the area along Smithville Highway. One parcel is almost completely surrounded by the city limits and the other has three sides connected to the city. Both are in the Northwood Lane area.

‘ Red Road ‘ There are 58 acres in the area of Hoover Drive and Garth Circle along Red Road. The parcels in between the two and land adjacent to it both are under consideration.

Before the commission’s recommendation to annex these areas reached the Board of Mayor and Aldermen, a petition against annexation signed by Bridge Builders Road residents did. The petition, consisting of around 50 signatures, stated property owners, ‘do not wish to be incorporated into the city limits.’

Although the question of annexation was directed to Finance Committee members Donald Hillis and Bobby Kirby, with Patti Nunley absent, they opened the discussion to the other elected officials present.

According to Alderman Billy Wood, it is an alderman’s responsibility to annex more of Warren County into the city. By law, the city can expand 25 percent every two years. Where other cities are doing what they are supposed to do to grow appropriately, McMinnville sits doing little, Wood said.

‘It takes a lot of courage to run for office, but it takes more courage to do your job when you get there,’ said Wood. ‘We’ve sat quietly for eight years and have not done our jobs. We are making the taxpayers of the city of McMinnville suffer because we are not increasing the tax base.’

Citing Cookeville as an example, Wood said that city has annexed as it should and because of that its tax rate is 85 cents.

Wood went on to say backing out on annexation due to protest from property owners is unfair to city taxpayers. ‘We’re not doing what they sent us here to do,’ Wood said.

Besides the services offered by the city, including city water, sewer and garbage pickup, which only city residents pay for and use, there are other city-paid-for benefits used by all. City residents paid for the Barren Fork Greenway and the walking trail at the Civic Center. However, there are no restrictions for their use.

After taking a walk along the greenway recently, Mayor Royce Davenport saw a familiar face. He, too, is ready to annex.

‘As we walked up the greenway, a gentleman who has been here half a dozen times yelling and screaming ‘I don’t want to be in the city of McMinnville. I have no use for the city or anything it offers’ was walking off the greenway,’ said Davenport. ‘I have no qualms about annexing into the city.’

Annexation takes courage and won’t win any city alderman a popularity contest, according to Wood.

‘It takes courage to do this job,’ said Wood. ‘If someone wants to kick you out of office for doing your job, there’s no shame in that. So, yeah I’m ready to annex all those areas. I don’t know where some of those areas are but that’s irrelevant.’

No final decision was made by Finance Committee members. However, Rutherford did instruct officials that annexation should be done before July 1 in order to get the city’s population certified.

Leave a Comment