Skip to content

GUILTY-Jury convicts Mathis on all counts

GUILTY-Jury convicts Mathis on all counts

Cheyenne
Former daycare owner Sherri Mathis will spend the rest of her life in prison after jurors found her guilty on all charges Tuesday afternoon for the death of 6-year-old Cheyenne Delp and the abuse of her two older brothers.

Mathis, 41, was emotionless as the jury foreman read the verdicts finding her guilty on each of nine criminal counts, the first two being first-degree murder by aggravated child abuse and neglect, both of which carry a mandatory life sentence.

Mathis was also found guilty on charges of aggravated child abuse for beating and choking Cheyenne and her brothers, David and Ryan, both of whom are now teens and both of whom testified against her during trial.

Mathis, who was placed in handcuffs and led to a waiting patrol car moments after hearing the verdict, is being held without bond pending sentence April 23 and will likely soon be moved to the state penitentiary for women.

Circuit Court Judge Bart Stanley revoked Mathis’ bond, saying the severity of the crime demanded it. The law also does not allow bond pending sentencing for Class B felonies or higher.

‘We knew from the beginning this would be a difficult case involving a difficult cause of death, strangulation versus medication,’ said defense attorney Michael Galligan, who argued the heavy medication Cheyenne was prescribed caused her to have a fatal heart attack. ‘We knew the pictures would have exceptional impact and would be difficult to try and overcome.’

Those pictures, taken at River Park Hospital where Cheyenne was pronounced dead, and taken later during autopsy, showed the child covered with scabs and bruises.

Despite those bruises, Mathis said she had given the child a bath earlier in the day and not noticed any of them ‘ a statement that likely crippled her credibility.

The verdict came at 3 p.m. Tuesday after jurors deliberated all day. They heard a full day of closing statements Monday, along with a briefing on the law by Judge Stanley and opted to adjourn Monday and return to deliberate Tuesday.

Jurors poured over eight days worth of testimony in the jury room even as another trial was taking place in the courtroom they had occupied for the past two weeks. The current trial, that involving a home invasion and rape, was temporarily adjourned while the alleged rape victim was on the stand to allow the report of the Mathis verdict.

The verdict came after prosecutors proved Mathis beat and abused the child over a period of years, the last incident ending in the death of the 33-pound child on June 26, 2004 at the Mathis home where Cheyenne and her brothers had lived for nearly three years. Mathis had custody of the children because their parents had legal issues.

Leave a Comment