Jurors have several angles to consider
|
Here’s a recap of the case in which prosecutors claim Mathis strangled 6-year-old Cheyenne Delp on June 26, 2004.
Damaging Prosecution Evidence
Pictures worth a million words: Pictures showing a multitude of injuries on Cheyenne’s body are the most damaging evidence against Mathis. The pictures of the child taken at autopsy show a variety of injuries to most areas of the body, the most horrendous to the child’s side and back.
Forensic pathologist Dr. Bruce Levy suggested a pattern of abuse while the defense maintained they were inflicted by Cheyenne herself because of her self-mutilating behavior brought on by her mental illness.
However, the appearance of at least some of the back injuries being the result of whipping marks, and Mathis claiming she did not see many of the marks while giving the child a bath hours before her death, leave the pictures as a piece of strong evidence for the state.
Direct testimony by
brothers claimis abuse
Cheyenne’s older brothers, Ryan and David, who are now teenagers, recalled being beaten with a belt and choked by Mathis during their three-year stay at her home. Both youths said their sister was also beaten and choked, the boys claiming they feared for their lives during the choking incidents.
The defense maintained the boys were coached by their biological parents to lie against their former guardian. The specific descriptions of being choked were compelling as one youth described how it felt to nearly lose consciousness while another described how his brother was turning white and trying to scream but could not during one incident he witnessed.
Their claims of abuse and choking bolster the pictorial proof.
Testimony by pathologist Dr. Bruce Levy
State pathologist Bruce Levy found Cheyenne died as result of strangulation. His testimony was convincing given his experience and extensive knowledge of forensics. Levy pointed to marks on the child’s throat, tracing them in his autopsy to the muscles below where the prints were mirrored suggesting some amount of strength had to be used to inflict the marks thus casting doubt on the defense theory the marks were put there by Cheyenne during her habitual scratching.
Dr. Levy also pointed out he could have called her death undetermined had he not been sure of the cause of death, dispelling the chance of the child dying due to a reaction to her medication.
The defense
strikes back
Lack of obvious motive: While the state has suggested Mathis tried to get financial benefit through Social Security for the three Delp children, the evidence has shown Mathis ended up paying thousands to support the children while they were in her care while getting little money in return. Her testimony showed she had taken the children in to help out the biological parents, who were in legal trouble, and she had planned for the parents to take the children back once they were financially able.
Although the state has laid some groundwork suggesting Mathis may have been angry when she whipped the children, there has been no evidence to show Mathis had an explosive temper.
Alternate cause
of death
The most powerful witness for the defense was its last as pharmacologist Dr. Opless Walker told jurors he was sure the child died from a reaction to a lethal cocktail of prescription drugs she had been taking for a year. Dr. Walker pointed to high levels of metabolized drugs in the system saying the buildup was to a point where it had become toxic. Walker used medical records from autopsy to show his point, suggesting prosecutors had disregarded the lab reports after Levy called the death a strangulation.
Testimony of Mathis’
immediate family
Testimony by Mathis’ daughters, now 12 and 16, seemed credible with both saying that while whipped with a belt as punishment by their mother, neither was whipped hard and neither was ever choked. They maintained they were all treated the same, and said the Delp children seemed happy while in the house.
The X-Factors
The Mudumbi impact: Testimony suggesting Cheyenne was overmedicated and given toxic levels of drugs not approved by the FDA by child psychiatrist Dr. Saran Mudumbi could lead to a transfer of some blame for the child’s death. Mudumbi admitted giving the child what he called ‘dangerous’ medications.
Mathis’ testimony
While having to testify to likely have any chance, Sherri Mathis’ testimony could be a two-edged sword. While coming across as a woman whose only motive was to help the Delp children, Mathis’ apparent coolness on the stand could also leave jurors with a negative feeling. Her inability to recall seeing several of the severe wounds on Cheyenne’s back also hurt her testimony.
Cheyenne’s
mental illness
Jurors were left with two different pictures when listening to witnesses recall the behavior of Cheyenne, one group saying she seemed to be close to normal and another group saying she suffered serious mental issues. Either one group was lying, or the child had suffered major mental setbacks the final year of her life.
The credibility that Cheyenne inflicted the injuries to herself seen in the autopsy photos is vital to the defense.
Potential verdicts
The top charge facing Mathis is first-degree murder by aggravated child abuse, a crime which carries life in prison, should jurors find Mathis killed the child by strangulation. Prosecutors are no longer alleging Mathis is responsible for overdosing the child and there was no evidence of a drug overdose, only a drug reaction caused by a combination of prescribed drugs.
After the top charge, there is an almost unlimited number of lesser included offenses to not only the first-degree murder charge but also the other indicted charges against Mathis which include charges ranging as high as second-degree murder to aggravated child abuse.
In addition to the death of Cheyenne, jurors will have to decide if they believe her brothers, who are also listed as victims in the aggravated child abuse portion of the case. The charge of aggravated child abuse carries 15 to 25 years in prison and also has its long list of lesser included offenses going all the way down to assault.
Reading of the law to jurors before their deliberation Monday could prove to be a long affair given the large number of potential verdicts they could reach.
Mathis trial recap
Dr. James Parker
River Park ER
Dr. Parker testified he was surprised by Sherri Mathis’ demeanor when he told her of Cheyenne’s death. He said Mathis didn’t show sorrow. Instead she launched into a series of explanations.
Dr. Saran Mudumbi
Child psychiatrist
Dr. Mudumbi testified he prescribed Cheyenne five different medications, which the child took daily. Some experts have questioned the combination of drugs ‘ with some even saying they led to her death.
Dr. Bruce Levy
Forensic pathologist
Dr. Levy conducted the autopsy on Cheyenne Delp and is convinced she died due to strangulation. He also found signs of battered child syndrome.

