School Board members change their votes; new calendar fails-Move would have put all schools on same schedule
|
A standing-room-only crowd of teachers, students, parents, concerned citizens and school administrators gathered at the School Board meeting to discuss the hot-button issue of a consolidated school calendar for the 2008-09 school year.
Board members Edd Cantrell and Bob Young voted for the schedule submitted by the Calendar Committee during the Curriculum Committee meeting, where the only dissenting vote from the board’s six members came from committee chairman Mike Holland.
But after returning from a short break between committee meetings and the full School Board meeting, Cantrell and Young changed their votes to no, generating a 3-3 stalemate.
Board chairman John Turner and members Larry Judkins and Gordon McGee Jr., voted yes, while Holland, Cantrell and Young voted no.
McGee expressed his surprise at the turn of events.
‘I’m going to say that I’m disappointed in the board as a whole,’ McGee said. ‘I think we brought something out of committee that was talked about and discussed and hashed out, and then we go out in the hall and we play hall politics. And I understand why you’re afraid, don’t get me wrong. It just seems strange that we come back and we do this.’
The proposed calendar features an Aug. 7 start and a May 28 closing date, with week-long breaks in October, November and March, and a two-week Christmas break from Dec. 20 to Jan. 4.
It would have ended the school system’s eight-year dual calendar, which had Bobby Ray Elementary on a 45-15 and later a 45-10 schedule, while the rest of the system maintained a traditional schedule.
The new calendar generated a fair amount of controversy when it was released earlier this month and spread rapidly around the community, drawing a sizable group of concerned citizens to the meeting, including local businessman and Industrial Development Board member Mark Brown.
‘It’s true there’s not an overwhelming amount of data supporting a non-traditional calendar,’ Brown said. ‘Likewise, there are no significant theories supporting a traditional calendar either. In fact it seems as if the entire issue is just a personal preference.’
Brown suggested the school system present a survey to parents, as was done a couple of years ago, to determine the calendar starting date, but Curriculum Committee chairman Mike Holland pointed out state law mandates county school boards set the calendar.
After the calendar vote reached a stalemate on its second vote, Middle School principal Betty Wood, a member of the Calendar Committee, said the group had done a lot of work and preparation, and there were good reasons for their decisions, not the least of which was a consolidated calendar. Wood also said the calendar provided enough instructional time to prepare for TCAPs and professional development time for teachers.
Wood went on to say most of those opposed to the calendar objected to the early start, and actually would like to see it moved back to after Labor Day
‘I would agree with that if you could move TCAP back too and give us the instructional days we need to do this thing and do it right, and we would all be for that,’ Wood said. ‘For us as teachers, and as instructors, we put together what we thought was best for teachers, and what we thought was best for students.’
Wood said she is willing to try the new calendar at the middle school and believes it’s a good compromise.
In the end, the stalemate remained unbroken, and the calendar failed to pass, leaving the school system with no set calendar for the 2008-09 school year. The document has to be turned in to the state by May, so the board has three more meetings to pass a calendar.

