Skip to content

Delp whipped day she died

Delp whipped day she died

Dr. Regina Reuter testifies she was concerned by an injury to Cheyenne Delp’s mouth.
A psychologist testified Friday that Cheyenne Delp’s two brothers told her they heard their sister being whipped twice by accused murderess Sherri Mathis the day she died.

The testimony was given while the state continued its portrayal of the former Small Wonders daycare owner as a monster who beat and strangled her wards of the court until 6-year-old Cheyenne died allegedly at her hands.

Meanwhile, the defense for Mathis continues to maintain she tried her best to cope with a small child who had serious mental problems, noting even first-responders found her over the child administering CPR when they arrived the day of her death.

‘Sherri was doing CPR when I got there,’ said medical first-responder Donald Hillis of his arrival at the Mathis home on June 26, 2004. Hillis noted the girl already felt cool and was without color.

Mathis is accused of strangling the girl to death as part of a pattern of child abuse perpetrated against Cheyenne, and her brothers, Ryan and David, both of whom have been key prosecution witnesses thus far. The three were all in the legal custody of Mathis after they were awarded to her by the court because their natural parents were having legal issues.

Prosecutors maintain Mathis made up psychological problems about Cheyenne to both explain marks on the child’s body ‘ which caused four Department of Children’s Services referrals ‘ and to get disability checks from the government through the child. The defense maintains all the psychological issues were legitimate concerns of the veteran daycare owner and mother of three.

During testimony by Vanderbilt psychologist Dr. Erin Fowler, she said it would be highly unusual to have a case of schizophrenia in a 6-year-old as reportedly suggested by Mathis, who maintained Cheyenne was hearing voices and hurting herself.

Fowler tended to back up testimony offered earlier by the brothers, now both teenagers, who said Mathis would beat and choke them.

‘David told me one time he almost passed out before she stopped choking him,’ Fowler recalled, saying she spoke to the boys weeks after the death of their sister. ‘Ryan told me he was told by Ms. Mathis ‘not to tell a damn thing about what happened in their house.’

While Fowler said the boys were both direct about being beaten and choked and about their sister being whipped twice the day she died, defense attorney John Partin pointed out neither boy told investigators about the choking incidents when interviewed just days before the psychological interview.

‘Many children are prone to suggestion, especially in younger ages like 2 through 5, and then lesser as they get older,’ Fowler confirmed after defense attorney John Partin told her their mother, Roxanne Haga, had told them that Cheyenne had been strangled to death.

Fowler also said it would not be unusual for the boys to keep silent about the choking incidents.

‘Many children are intimidated and afraid,’ Dr. Fowler said of silence over the abuse.

As for specific abuse suffered by Cheyenne prior to her death, Dr. Regina Reuter said she saw the child a couple of years before her death, noting she was suffering an injury to the roof of her mouth which concerned her. Dr. Reuter said the girl’s brothers told her the injury was caused by Mathis holding the girl down and force feeding her, pushing the spoon into her mouth. The boys were 6 and 7 at the time.

Along with injuries sustained by the child as witnessed by daycare workers and school teachers, prosecutors brought several witnesses to the stand who testified Mathis exaggerated the psychological issues suffered by Cheyenne. They said Cheyenne appeared to be basically a normal child and did not display any schizophrenic issues.

‘She was a delight to be around,’ said Cheryl Hitchcock, who served as a special education teacher.

The prosecution’s case continues Monday morning at Warren County Courthouse.

Leave a Comment