Skip to content

Buck refuses to testify in Mathis case

An attorney who represented accused murderess Sherri Mathis in getting custody of three children in 2001, one of whom the former daycare owner is accused of killing, refused to testify against her former client Friday citing attorney-client privilege.

The attorney, Lena Buck, wife of state Rep. Frank Buck, cited the legal cannons of attorney-client privilege when she took the stand Friday after being called to testify by the prosecution in the murder case against Sherri Mathis.

‘I would ask the court to direct the witness to testify,’ said special prosecutor Brian Holmgren.

Circuit Court Judge Bart Stanley then directed Buck to cooperate with testimony, noting the information she needed to give would not violate any privilege.

‘The court won’t ask for any private information about your client,’ Judge Stanley said in directing Buck to testify.

However, the veteran attorney resisted, suggesting the court recess and allow her to call the Board of Professional Responsibility for an opinion.

‘It’s serious when you give testimony about a client,’ Buck said, prompting Judge Stanley to adjourn to chambers to make the call.

Minutes later the group emerged from chambers, with Buck walking to the court gallery.

‘She will not be compelled to testify,’ Judge Stanley announced, reversing his previous decision. ‘It’s simply not appropriate to call an attorney to testify against a client so we won’t.’

While not going into detail, it is believed the call of the Board of Professional Responsibility netted an opinion in which the court was told Buck should not be compelled to testify.

It was not revealed what Buck would have been asked if she had cooperated. She did represent Mathis in a custody case over Cheyenne Delp and her two brothers in which Mathis was granted custody by Juvenile Court Judge Larry Ross.

The Department of Children’s Services had sought to place the siblings into foster care.

Leave a Comment