Prosecutor calls Mathis consummate liar
The prosecution claims that Mathis, over a period of three years, callously neglected and abused the child before choking her to death on the afternoon of June 26, 2004.
Which version of the contrasting portraits of 41-year-old Sherri Mathis the jury believes will determine if she’s found guilty of first-degree murder for the death of Cheyenne Delp, a girl who was supposedly placed in the Mathis home for her own well-being.
Opening arguments in the trial began Wednesday morning with special prosecutor Brian Holmgren of Davidson County calling Mathis ‘a lying, manipulative, abusive, murderer.’
‘If there’s anything at all that’s accomplished during the course of this trial, it’s that Mrs. Mathis is a consummate liar who lies repeatedly and persistently,’ said Holmgren, who proceeded to describe the condition of Cheyenne’s body when she was brought to River Park Hospital in an attempt to revive her.
‘Her body revealed dozens and dozens of bruises on virtually every surface of her body,’ said Holmgren, who said most significantly the child had fingernail marks on both sides of her neck. ‘There was no accounting of the bruises by the defendant ‘ We will prove Sherri Mathis murdered Cheyenne Delp by beating her, by strangling her.’
Defense attorney Jack Lowery immediately refuted all of Holmgren’s allegations and said this is a case of ‘unjust, overzealous prosecution.’
‘The things said about Sherri Mathis are not true,’ said Lowery, who quickly pointed out Mathis not only had Cheyenne in her home, but also her two brothers. ‘Sherri and her husband, Robert, took these children into their home with virtually no support from the biological parents and treated them as their own.’
Lowery says Cheyenne was watching TV when she went into a seizure that claimed her life, and that Mathis called 911 in an effort to save her.
‘You’ll hear the blood-curdling 911 call made by this child’s mother, the only mother she knew, and you’ll hear her frantically trying to save the life of this child,’ said Lowery. ‘This is a misguided, unjustified prosecution of this woman.’
In setting the framework for the state’s case against Mathis, Holmgren stressed this wasn’t an isolated incident but rather a three-year pattern of abusive behavior. Holmgren said Mathis was questioned about injuries that were repeatedly found on Cheyenne’s body ‘ and Mathis frequently changed her explanation about how those injuries occurred.
According to Holmgren, Mathis denied an apparent burn to the back of Cheyenne’s neck that was found by Brookside Head Start workers by saying it wasn’t there when she left the house.
According to Holmgren, Mathis said marks covering Cheyenne’s body were self-inflicted because the girl beat herself and bit herself 10 to 12 times a day.
According to Holmgren, Mathis said bruises on Cheyenne’s back were caused because the child liked to rock against molding in their home, and that Mathis also claimed Cheyenne was so disturbed she ate her own feces from the commode.
‘Mrs. Mathis made exaggerated claims of uncontrolled behavior, but you will hear from teachers and day care workers who saw Cheyenne every day and none of this would be seen by the other people in close contact with her,’ said Holmgren.
In response, Lowery said none of the abuse came at the hands of Mathis. And he said Cheyenne’s own brother would corroborate that claim.
‘Her own brother will testify how she would itch, scratch and bruise herself,’ said Lowery, who went on to say Mathis had painted Cheyenne’s toenails the day of her death.
In response to the prosecution’s claim that Mathis shifted Cheyenne from doctor to doctor in an attempt to get her more and more medicated, Lowery said Mathis was doing her best to deal with three children who had come from a drug-laden home.
‘Because they came from a home where illegal drugs were used, they had difficult behavior,’ said Lowery. ‘Cheyenne was referred to different doctors because these were medical decisions made by professional doctors after they had examined her. Sherri Mathis was doing everything in her power to help a troubled child.’
Holmgren contended Mathis barely fed Cheyenne and said she instructed school and day care workers to withhold food from her too. Holmgren said during Cheyenne’s three years in the Mathis home, she gained 2 pounds. When she died at age 6-1/2, Holmgren said she weighed 35 pounds.
Cheyenne lived in the Mathis home from September 2001 until her death in June 2004. Holmgren pointed out the first Department of Children’s Services investigation about mistreatment to Cheyenne began Oct. 5, 2001 due to a mouth injury.
On the stand:
Dorris Denton Department of Children’s Services-Denton went to the Mathis home to conduct an investigation about an injury to Cheyenne Delp’s mouth. The investigation, launched in October 2001, was less than a month after Cheyenne was first placed in the Mathis home in September 2001. Denton said Mrs. Mathis told her Cheyenne got the injury to her upper, inner mouth while choking on a corn chip. ‘Mrs. Mathis said she rammed the corn chip down her throat in an effort to get her unchoked,’ said Denton.
Angela Bratcher Bess Department of Children’s Services Bess conducted a home visit shortly after Cheyenne and her two brothers were placed in the Mathis home. Bess testified the children indicated they liked being in the home and that they ‘appeared to be normal children for that age.’
Bess said Mrs. Mathis told her she didn’t believe in corporal punishment (spanking) and that’s why her children attended Boyd Christian School. She also said Mrs. Mathis stressed health problems the children were having. ‘A lot of attention was paid to medical issues and these children didn’t appear to be sickly,’ said Bess.

