Skip to content

Child describes house of horror-Cheyenne Delp’s brothers testify

Child describes house of horror-Cheyenne Delp's brothers testify

CHEYENNE DELP
Describing a house of horror, the older brothers of Cheyenne Delp testified they and their sister were beaten and choked by the woman entrusted to care for them, abuse they say continued until their 6-year-old sister died allegedly at the hands of accused murderess Sherri Mathis.

‘I was scared. I thought I was going to die. I couldn’t breathe,’ testified Cheyenne’s older brother, Ryan, of being choked by Mathis during what he said was a regular routine of beatings and incidents of choking committed by their legal caregiver. ‘She would choke me until I stopped breathing, then she would let go.’

His testimony and that of his stepbrother, David, came during the first full day of testimony against the former Small Wonders day care owner accused of murder for allegedly strangling Cheyenne Delp to death on June 26, 2004 at the home of Mathis family where Cheyenne and her brothers were living at the order of the court.

The children were placed there when the boys were around six and seven and Cheyenne was three after their parents got into legal difficulties. They remained in Mathis’ custody until Cheyenne’s death.

‘I saw her doing the same thing to my brother David,’ Ryan recalled of the choking incidents, which he said would follow beatings with a belt. ‘He was trying to cry but couldn’t. His face was a white as a piece of paper.’

Ryan said Mathis would also beat his sister, with both brothers saying they would see marks on their younger sibling.

‘I could hear her screaming,’ Ryan recalled, saying Mathis would take them into her bedroom and beat them with a belt before sometimes choking them against a wall. ‘She would force feed her (Cheyenne) even when she was full and then, if she threw up while she was doing that, she’d make her eat that too.’

Ryan said the anger with which Mathis punished them, sometimes for no apparent reason, kept him in fear.

‘She told us if we ever told she would kill us,’ Ryan said of why he remained silent, even after his sister’s death. ‘It terrified me.’

His brother David, who would testify later, recalled many of the same incidents including being beaten with a belt and choked by Mathis.

While painting a disturbing picture of beatings and paranoid behaviors on the part of Mathis, the story of both boys was called into question by the defense which pointed to earlier video taped statements where the boys never mentioned such incidents.

‘Actually you told people you felt safe with Miss Sherri and this was said after you were no longer in her house,’ said defense attorney John Partin in reminding Ryan of his statement shortly after the death of his sister.

Partin went on to point out the boys had actually referred to their sister having behavioral issues which included her scratching and pinching herself and causing injuries to her own person. Prosecutors maintain Mathis told people Cheyenne was schizophrenic and had fictitious disorders to cover her abuse of the girl.

However, Ryan admitted he lied when first questioned by authorities concerning his sister’s hurting of herself, saying he was afraid he might be returned to Mathis and be punished for not backing up her story about why Cheyenne was constantly bruised.

Social workers who worked four referrals testified they looked into the complaints. One complaint involved a busted mouth, others bruises on the girl’s body. The complaints were filed by teachers and others who noticed injuries on the child.

While pictures of the injuries were shown in court and testimony was presented by Department of Children’s Services agents as to their investigations of the injuries, all said no charges were ever lodged against Mathis.

On the day of their sister’s death, the boys both testified they saw her briefly while on their way out the door to fill up a small swimming pool. David recalled his sister looking ‘green’ and wrapped in a sheet like she was having chills. It was shortly after that the boys said one of Mathis’ children came out screaming.

‘I heard screaming inside and then they came out and said Cheyenne was dead,’ David recalled.

On cross examination, Partin pointed out both boys had told investigators shortly after their sister’s death they had heard their sister vomiting the day of her death, something neither revealed during their direct testimony. While it was suggested the boys may have been coached regarding their testimony, both denied the allegation, staying they were telling the truth.

Leave a Comment