Skip to content

Mathis murder trial begins

A 10-man, five-woman jury will begin hearing evidence this morning in the case of a former daycare owner accused of murdering a 6-year-old child who was in her custody.

The defendant, Sherri Mathis, 41, entered a not guilty plea before jurors Tuesday afternoon to charges of first-degree murder, child abuse and child neglect for the death in 2004 of her court ward Cheyenne Delp, 6, and injuries allegedly sustained by her older brothers who were also in the care of Mathis.

Delp died under mysterious circumstances at the Mathis home where she lived. Prosecutors maintain Mathis abused the girl and her brothers and that she strangled the girl to death.

The defense will likely maintain Delp suffered from medical problems and may have died due to a reaction to a number of medications she was taking. The defense also contends Mathis tried to revive the girl before paramedics arrived.

The jurors were selected by 4 p.m. yesterday after a day full of jury selection. The 12 of the 15 jurors who actually determine the verdict will be chosen at random when the trial is complete. The other three will be released following evidence and are being kept as alternates.

Jurors were dismissed yesterday after hearing a reading of the indictments against Mathis and will begin their day today at 9 a.m. hearing opening arguments from the state and defense. The court has set aside two weeks to hear the case which will be presented by special prosecutor Brian Holmgren. District Attorney General Lisa Zavogiannis had to recuse herself from the case since she had represented Cheyenne Delp’s brothers.

Leave a Comment