Skip to content

Adult-oriented Web site under fire from county

A local business operating a Web site which sells explicit adult videos, as well as a wide variety of adult sex toys, has been found in violation of Warren County’s ordinances governing sexually oriented adult businesses.

The business, called Pleasures Down South, lists a Smartt Station post office box contact address on its Web site.

The operation was discovered when County Court Clerk Lesa Scott became aware of it through a report she receives on businesses which request sales tax numbers. Since businesses operating in the county are required to have a business license, Scott contacted the owner, Kimberly A. Pinegar, and sent a business license application by mail.

When the application was not returned in a timely manner, Scott again contacted the owner and during the subsequent conversation learned the name of the business, which lead her to suspect it might be an adult-oriented business. Further conversation revealed Pinegar’s business is an online adult novelty store.

When contacted by the Standard Pinegar said she had contacted the County Court Clerk’s office and was told all she needed was a regular business license.

‘They didn’t tell me I needed an adult-oriented business license,’ Pinegar said. ‘No one told me that. They told me all I needed was a regular business license, and I applied for that.’

Pinegar also wants to make it clear she is not selling any materials out of her home.

‘I’m just a sort of middle man,’ Pinegar said. ‘I take the orders on the Web site, turn them in to the distributor, and they ship them out. I never even see the merchandise.’

Even though Pinegar did apply for the Warren County business license, she failed to fill out the code on the application indicating the type of business. As a result, Scott took no action on the license application and turned it over to the county’s Adult Oriented Business Board for review. The five-member board was appointed by County Executive John Pelham early last year and includes chairman Earl Barr, Charles Bogle, Marvin Lusk, Linda Partin and Tommy Savage.

Upon reviewing the application, board members noticed the business showed a starting date of Nov. 1, 2007, and since the owners had never applied for an adult-oriented business license, and had only applied for a regular business license on Jan. 14 of this year, the board found it in violation of regulations.

After bringing the Web site up on the Internet and determining it was indeed an adult-oriented online store, the board voted unanimously to deny the regular business license and recommended the business be turned over to the proper authorities for investigation.

Though some board members questioned whether the board had any authority over an online business, Savage advised the board he had done some research and found an opinion issued by the Tennessee Attorney General which upheld the constitutionality of an amended definition of ‘adult bookstore’ in the Adult-Oriented Establishment Registration Act, which gave Tennessee counties the right to establish their own regulations governing adult-oriented businesses in their jurisdiction.

The definition upheld by the attorney general reads:

‘Adult bookstore means a business which offers, as its principal or predominate stock or trade, sexually oriented material, devices, or paraphernalia, specified sexual activities, or any combination or form thereof, whether printed, filmed, recorded or live and which restricts or purports to restrict admission to adults or to any class of adults and such definition shall specifically include items such as adult novelties, risqu?? gifts or marital aids that are, regardless of how labeled or sold, sexually oriented in nature.’

Savage believes this language effectively covers online or mail-order operations based in the county. Savage also noted he has some major concerns about online sales in particular.

‘With sales by electronic means or mail order, there’s no way to enforce the legal age limit,’ Savage said.

Barr agreed the attorney general’s opinion appears to cover online and mail-order sales.

‘That right there is pretty specific to me,’ Barr said. ‘Regardless of how it’s labeled or sold, that covers a broad area. You can’t get any broader than that.’

Partin said she was concerned the business had been operating for some time undetected.

‘Somehow we need to keep an eye on this,’ Partin said. ‘And I don’t know how you could do this. Somebody needs to constantly check for this. Maybe the codes/environmental officer we’re talking about hiring could do that.’

Pinegar says she does not plan to close the online store, but may move the base to another county if she fails to obtain the required license here.

Leave a Comment