Skip to content

Tennessee tops nation in bankruptcy filings-Warren County’s district has 56 percent increase

Tennessee tops nation in bankruptcy filings-Warren County's district has 56 percent increase
Tennessee had the highest rate of personal bankruptcy filings per household in the nation last year.

And the state’s Eastern District, of which Warren County is a part, didn’t help matters. The Eastern District saw bankruptcies rise 56 percent in 2007, and that trend has continued in 2008.

Based on figures which have already been compiled, bankruptcy filings increased another 27 percent from January 2007 compared to January 2008.

‘That’s the trend and it’s the trend not only throughout Tennessee but the whole country,’ said U.S. Bankruptcy Court Judge R. Thomas Stinnett, who has presided over bankruptcy cases in this district for 14 years. ‘It’s sort of a cultural thing and people around here tend to accept bankruptcy more.’

Bankruptcy is filed in federal court, not at the local or state levels. Statistics are kept by district and Warren County cases are heard at the federal courthouse in Winchester.

According to information from the National Bankruptcy Research Center, one in every 59 households in Tennessee filed for bankruptcy in 2007. That translates to more than 38,500 households.

Judge Stinnett provided a long list of reasons why Warren County residents are filing for bankruptcy. He said a high divorce rate, recent plant closures, and a late freeze and summer-long drought that pounded the nursery industry are three reasons that come to mind.

‘There were a lot of people who came in after all the plants closed in your area,’ said Stinnett. ‘Even if they were able to find another job, it didn’t pay nearly as much.’

Local attorney Keith Smartt handles a number of bankruptcy cases and he listed many of the same reasons why local residents are filing for bankruptcy. He also mentioned the check advance industry as playing a major role in financial struggles.

‘If you look at Warren County over the last 10 years, the main business growth has been predatory lenders,’ said Smartt. ‘It’s a vicious cycle when someone borrows against their next paycheck or borrows against their car. Their business model is simple. Loan out a small amount of money and routinely refinance that amount to keep them in regular payments and keep them in debt as long as possible.’

With bankruptcy filings on the rise, Judge Stinnett said he wants to clear up one misconception.

‘People have the misunderstanding that in bankruptcy you don’t have to pay and you get to keep everything,’ said Stinnett. ‘That is absolutely not the case. If you borrowed money to buy it ‘ and that’s everything including a car, house, four-wheeler, furniture ‘ if you don’t pay for it, you don’t get to keep it.’

On thing bankruptcy does accomplish is it buys more time for homeowners behind on their mortgage payments. Judge Stinnett said the home foreclosure procedure in Tennessee is relatively simple, and that it’s easy for a lending institution to foreclose and have a family removed from their home. Stinnett said a bankruptcy can delay a foreclosure for up to five years ‘ although the debt is not erased.

‘We’ll end up certainly with a lot more bankruptcies because of the subprime issue,’ said Nashville bankruptcy attorney William L. Norton III.

Smartt estimated that 20 to 25 percent of the people he represents declare bankruptcy because of medical expenses. He said medical bill collectors are among the most ruthless in the collection business.

‘If you take someone without insurance, or someone with insurance and a high co-pay, and they have to spend a week in the hospital, they could end up with a $10,000 or $20,000 bill,’ said Smartt. ‘Most people can’t withstand that.’

Smartt also said shady mortgage origination companies are responsible for a number of bankruptcies. He stressed that these are not our local banks, but rather out-of-town companies that rope people into extremely low interest rates and don’t disclose that the rates will skyrocket in a couple years.

‘These companies are getting away with grand theft on the most massive scale,’ said Smartt.

He also emphasized that the local economy hasn’t helped household finances either.

‘Downsizing the industrial component, where we’ve lost some 4,000 jobs, has been a big factor,’ said Smartt. ‘You take people who had jobs that paid $15 to $20 an hour with benefits, and put them in jobs that pay $8 or $9 an hour without benefits and even those who have been relatively prudent have trouble making it work.’

Judge Stinnett said reducing the bankruptcy rate will ultimately depend on people exercising more personal responsibility.

‘It’s really a matter of wants than a matter of needs,’ said Stinnett. ‘Just because you want a 50-inch flat-screen doesn’t mean you can pay for it. But there are people out there who will sell it to you on credit.’

Bankruptcy stats: Tennessee Eastern District Court

Filings in 2006 ‘ 494

Filings in 2007 ‘ 772

Percent increase ‘ 56%

January 2007 ‘ 56

January 2008 ‘ 71

Percent increase ‘ 27%

Leave a Comment