City votes yes to buy Regions Bank building
|
The decision divided the board and passed with a 4-3 vote with Mayor Royce Davenport breaking the tie at Tuesday night’s meeting.
Aldermen Bobby Kirby and Jimmy Haley, as well as Vice Mayor Donald Hillis, voted against purchasing the building. Aldermen Patti Nunley, Rick Barnes and Billy Wood voted for it.
The three-story building is 35,636 square feet and has a basement. Comparing purchase price to square feet, the price is about $19 a square foot.
Also, the property is valued at $1 million and the city will lose approximately $7,200 a year in taxes. However, it will gain almost $30,000 in revenue with the Regions Bank lease, which is for the first floor only.
In addition to the purchase price, officials will have to spend an estimated $100,000 for elevator repairs, an unknown amount on the ventilation system, and an estimated $175,000 to move city hall into the building.
The funding for the purchase and move will come from $800,000 in capital outlay notes. The notes will be paid back at about $100,000 per year for the next 12 years ‘ around $1.2 million.
Maintenance and ventilation work will be paid for by the city or by an alternate funding process.
The purchase went against the recommendation of the two realtors and the historian on the board.
‘There are two things,’ said Kirby with agreement from Hillis. ‘If we are going to look at purchasing the building, we should offer less than the asking price of $675,000. And the other is can the lease agreement with Regions Bank be re-negotiated? The lease is very favorable to the tenant that is currently there. I would not buy that, and I would not recommend that to a buyer with the current lease. I’m not in favor of this at all.’
The owner of the building is American Financial Realty Trust. Two years ago, that company signed a 15-year lease with Regions Bank. For the next 13 years, the bank will get the use of the first floor of the building for under $30,000 a year.
The lease agreement is slightly over $3 a square foot and does not include utilities, taxes, insurance or maintenance, which are paid by the building’s owner. Utility bills for the whole building are estimated at $26,000 annually.
‘You’ll spend the $3 on utilities, insurance and janitorial,’ said Kirby. ‘You’re getting nothing. That’s not a lease I would want to buy. That’s not a good investment. That’s horrible from a landlord standpoint.’
It was recommended by Kirby for the city to take some time and negotiate a better price on the building and check into the possibility of re-negotiating the lease agreement with Regions. While negotiating, a maintenance program can be worked out for the Blue Building.
The rush to purchase the building was puzzling to Haley who added, ‘I’m not sure if this is the right time to rush through with an ordinance. I was a little shocked when I received my package and the actual ordinance was already included. We still don’t have a full evaluation regarding the facility itself or what will happen to this building,’ he said referring to the Blue Building.
Also, Haley said people have voiced concerns to him that if the city spent years using a building and spending very little money on maintenance, why would they spend money on it after they leave?
‘If we do go to a new facility, I hope we vote some money into stabilizing this building until a study is done,’ said Haley. ‘Non-maintenance of the building will lead to eventual demolition. I just want to make sure we do what is right for the citizens and just not in terms of dollars.’
According to Nunley, the purchase of the bank building should not be viewed as the board’s decision to demolish the Blue Building.
‘What this ordinance says is that the city of McMinnville for a number of years has needed more adequate office space and its not available here,’ said Nunley. ‘What we are talking about tonight is providing an office building for the city of McMinnville and not the eventual outcome of this building.’
Although she voted for the purchase, Nunley says she has emotional attachment to the Blue Building. For 18 years, her husband’s father was the principal and they have the bell he rung every day to call the school into session. Along with Nunley, her mother and children went to school there.
‘I think opportunity and need have collided,’ said Wood. ‘At $19 a square foot for that building, you can’t wire and plumb one for that.’
In agreement with Wood was Barnes who added, ‘This is a good deal.’
If purchased, McMinnville’s Planning and Zoning Department will move into the building. For years, the city has discussed moving the two together so residents will have ‘one-stop’ convenience when it comes to city business.
There was no discussion regarding McMinnville Police Department relocation. However, it was discussed that city traffic court will go with the police department to its new location.
The measure will have to pass one more reading before the Board of Mayor and Aldermen. That vote is scheduled for Jan. 22.

