Civic Center to get $1.2M heating and cooling system
Despite the $1.2 million pricetag, McMinnville Civic Center will receive its upgrade to a geothermal heating and cooling system. City officials passed the resolution Tuesday night after they agreed the Civic Center’s future is worth the long-term investment.
Several months ago, the cost of installing a geothermal system to replace the conventional system was estimated at $750,000 by Townsend Engineering. However, when the bids came in several weeks ago, the lowest and best offers totaled $1.2 million.
CHC Mechanical bid $873,000 for the mechanical work on the inside of the Civic Center, and Mid-State Construction bid $348,092 for the outside geothermal installation.
The reason the initial estimate was so much lower is because the cost of the well field was left out. When it comes to the project, there is inside mechanical, outside geothermal and well field.
Leaving out the well field lowered the initial estimate by $340,000.
With the added cost, officials considered not going with a geothermal system and instead going with replacing the existing conventional system with one just like it. However, after being asked, CHC Mechanical priced a conventional system at $650,000 with a 10-12 year life span. Geothermal, at $1.2 million, has a life span of 20-30 years.
Doubling the cost for conventional to match the life span of geothermal raised the cost of conventional to $1.3 million. Given the expected energy savings of geothermal being between $750,000 and $900,000 over that life span, and unknown increases in electrical prices over the next 10-30 years, the geothermal system is expected to be a significant savings to taxpayers.
‘When you start looking at all the aspects, it comes down to pay me now or pay me later,’ said City Administrator David Rutherford. ‘Do you make a long-term investment and move forward realizing the savings down the path, or do you use the approach we’ve used in the past to fix it as cheap as we can and move forward.’
Also considered was making changes to the bid to help drop the price. However, taking items out of the bid will leave a project people might not be satisfied with in the long run.
‘If you take a project that you spend time designing and actually go out and bid then you start trying to save $1 here and $5 over there, you’ll end up without the project that you wanted,’ said Rutherford.
For instance, among the bids was one under $1 million. In that bid, the well field would be moved from the ballfield to the back parking lot. Once the work is finished, the area would have to be re-paved. Given a problem, the pavement would have to be ripped up again at city taxpayers expense.
‘To me the savings aren’t there,’ said Alderman Bobby Kirby. ‘You save a little bit of cost in piping but we would spend almost all that savings if we had to go back and redo the parking lot. I’m convinced that geothermal is the best way to go. I’m just not happy with the cost.’
The complete $1.2 million project will require an annual payment of $120,000 for the next 12 years. The project still has an $500,000 interest-free energy loan and a low-interest loan will be used for the rest.
According to Alderman Jimmy Haley, if updating the Civic Center with an indoor pool and activity center is in the long-term future of the city, a long-term investment should be made in heating and cooling.
‘If we aren’t committed to the pool and rehabbing the building to make it usable, and if we are going to continue patching up, covering up and painting over, then there is no sense spending this kind of money,’ said Haley. ‘We can get some big fans in there and some kerosene heaters. We can make do with what we’ve got and save a lot of money.’
After voicing their opinions that they were all committed to the long-term future of the Civic Center, and given all the information they were presented by Rutherford, the board unanimously passed the resolution to move forward with geothermal.
