With city hall deteriorating, local residents must decide if the Blue Building is ‘History worth keeping-From home to school, building rich in memor
|
McMinnville officials are expected to continue contemplating those questions, and others, until budget talks next year. They face the difficult task of acting in the best interest of the city, while also weighing potential public backlash.
‘As you drive by city hall in the future, remember this ‘ no site in McMinnville has contributed more to our advancement in the past 100 years than this one,’ said Warren County historian James A. Dillon, who provided the historical information for this article. ‘I wonder what the next 100 years holds.’
There won’t be another 100 years if a proposal to level the facility and construct a new city hall is adopted. This idea generated public outcry recently when the building made its way into the ‘Preparing McMinnville for Tomorrow’ 10-year plan as a restoration or demolition project suggested by city administrator David Rutherford.
Rutherford says city officials have discussed the Blue Building situation for around two decades but have never taken action.
‘For the last 20 years or so, they have discussed it and done nothing,’ said Rutherford. ‘The building belongs to the city taxpayers. If they decide they want to keep the building, that’s fine. If they decide they don’t want to keep it, that’s fine. A decision should be made.’
Since the first house was built on the site 138 years ago, it has been used as a home, school and city hall. Now, it faces a future yet to be determined.
The original home was built between the summer of 1869 and June 1871 by John Pickett, a Louisiana plantation owner who purchased 5 acres and built the home at the request of his brother, James Pickett. The $29,000 pricetag left James bankrupt and he never moved into the house.
For several years, little is known about the occupancy of the building. In 1881, Col. E.W. Munford, a noted Memphis attorney and former colonel of the Confederate Army, purchased the house. After renovation, he and his wife, Mary Elizabeth, lived there until their deaths.
The house was subsequently deeded to Blanche Lewis. Upon her death in 1902, the house was passed on to her heirs until 1915 when they sold it to the Board of Education for $10,000 to use as a public school.
As it evolved from home to school, a $30,000 renovation project partially demolished the house while leaving the foundation which was incorporated into the school’s foundation. The school was opened in January 1916 for 12 grades.
In 1928, with the construction of the new County Central High School, the school went from 12 grades to grammar school only. Deemed unsafe for educational purposes in 1977 by the state fire marshal, school days came to an end and the city hall days began.
Despite it’s majestic beginnings as a glamorous mansion where the Munford’s were noted for their hospitality, lavish dining and gracious Southern living, the building that stands now is a shadow of its former glory.
The building has deteriorated ‘ and crumbled ‘ to the point where city officials are discussing what to do about the situation. Currently, government business is limited to the first floor, which serves as city hall, and the basement, which serves as McMinnville Police Department.
Access to the second and third floors is restricted due to current conditions. However, Rutherford offered several weeks ago to give tours of the building to residents who agree to sign a waiver first. To date, one city employee has asked permission and no residents have.
After being invited, the Southern Standard was given access to the building for a walk-thru and allowed to take pictures.
The findings of this tour are as follows:
‘ Throughout the building, there are areas that have structural damage, mold and crumbling walls. Despite the heating and air capabilities, temperatures vary not only from floor to floor, but from room to room. Several rooms have their own heating and air units based on need.
Description of the floors:
‘ Third floor ‘ Despite the outward appearance, the third floor’s ceilings, floors, walls and windows are all damaged by moisture and what appears to be mold is present. Some of the windows and walls are being held up by wood studs and the floor has noticeable areas of weakness. There is no electricity, heating or cooling available, and there are dead bats, birds and animal droppings.
‘ Second floor ‘ Slightly better, but not by much. The second floor has the same problems as the third.
‘ First floor ‘ Since this area is used to house city government offices, attempts have been made to maintain the area. However, along the ceilings and outer walls, moisture damage is present and appears to be moving down the walls and into the carpet.
Major complaints by employees working on the first floor include the temperature changes due to lack of insulation, leaks when it rains, and bat infestation.
‘ Basement ‘ Since this section is used to house the police department, attempts have also been made to maintain the area. However, moisture has run down the walls and onto the floor. Because of this, the floors were replaced with concrete but the carpets on these floors still have to be changed out periodically because of mold.
Major complaints include an intense odor from mildew and mold, puddles of water forming inside during rain, brown recluse spider infestation, and termites.
‘ Gym and auditorium ‘ Both these areas are in poor condition with walls crumbing, water damage, and no insulation.
Currently, no tests have been done to determine if the building is safe structurally or environmentally. Tours are still offered to those who are willing to sign a waiver.

