Clinton could lose nomination
I used to say if you put a gun to my head and demanded to know who’d be the 2008 Republican presidential nominee, my answer would be: “Shoot.” Now, I’m almost ready to say the same about the Democratic nominee and the next president, too.
I still think the likeliest answer to the last two questions is Sen. Hillary Rodham Clinton, D-N.Y., but that’s a lot less certain than it used to be.
Meanwhile, the Republican race is boiling down to two major contestants, former New York Mayor Rudy Giuliani and former Massachusetts Gov. Mitt Romney, but who’s going to win is still unknowable.
Polling continues to show that Americans favor a generic Democratic candidate as their next president and that only Giuliani or Sen. John McCain, R-Ariz., has much of a chance against top Democrats.
But once the nominees are known, the clock will be reset and the race will tighten. The Democrat might be favored, but issues of executive experience and foreign policy could make it a contest.
In the race for the Democratic nomination, if Clinton wins the Iowa caucuses Jan. 3, she’s almost certain to be the nominee. But now you can easily see her losing in Iowa. And if she finishes third or significantly trails as No. 2 — especially behind Sen. Barack Obama (Illinois) — it could set off a cascade that causes her to lose New Hampshire and then the nomination.
Polls suggest Clinton has built up lots of firewalls in states after New Hampshire, where she currently leads by 13 points. She leads in Michigan (Jan. 15) and Nevada (Jan. 19) by more than 20 points, according to RealClearPolitics.com averages, South Carolina (Jan. 26) by 12 points and Florida (Jan. 29) by 26 points.
And in Feb. 5 states like California, New Jersey and Pennsylvania, her leads are close to 30 points.
Yet, defeats in Iowa and New Hampshire could burn through the firewalls and re-create the dynamic of 1984, where the establishment candidate, former Vice President Walter Mondale, almost lost the nomination to fresh-face challenger Sen. Gary Hart (Colorado).
Mondale pulled it out only because his staff succeeded in convincing the media that Georgia and Alabama were the key contests on Super Tuesday. Mondale won them, though Hart won bigger states like Florida, Massachusetts and Washington, and even bigger primaries later in Ohio and California.
The way the Iowa caucuses work, after a first round of balloting, candidates receiving less than 15 percent support get dropped on subsequent ballots, putting a premium on being the second choice of caucus-goers.
In early November, the CBS/New York Times poll indicated that Edwards was the second choice of 30 percent of supporters of second-tier candidates, while Obama was favored by 27 percent and Clinton by just 14 percent.
If caucus-goers between now and January decide that they need to support the candidate best able to win the presidency in November and best qualified to govern, they’ll pick Clinton, much as they dropped Howard Dean for Sen. John Kerry (Massachusetts) in 2004.
If they primarily want someone who says what he thinks and understands the problems of people in Iowa, it will be Edwards. If they opt for trying to change Washington, it will be Obama — according to current polls.
It’s hard to see how Edwards goes on to win the nomination even if he wins in Iowa. He’s running a distant third in New Hampshire and everywhere else.
Obama is more likely to defeat Clinton for the nomination — especially if an Iowa victory makes him the top story of the night and excites Independents in New Hampshire to vote in the Democratic primary.
So, bottom line, Clinton still has an edge, but it’s nothing to bet much money on. If you’re inclined to do so, though, Ladbrokes of London puts the odds on Clinton at 1-2, Giuliani at 7-2, Romney at 11-2, Obama at 8-1 and Edwards at 25-1.
Morton Kondracke is executive editor of Roll Call, the newspaper of Capitol Hill.
