Tune out extended TV warranties
There’s mounting evidence that flat-panel LCD and plasma TVs have been highly reliable products that require few repairs during the first three years. These findings reinforce Consumer Reports’ standing advice that consumers should say no to an extended warranty. Rear-projection TVs have been more repair-prone, but even for these sets, an extended warranty usually won’t pay off. That’s the news from Consumer Reports’ latest reader survey, which covers almost 93,000 TV sets.
While some brands have been more trouble-prone than others, if consumers choose wisely, there’s no reason to pay the typical $200 to $400 for an extended warranty. But be prepared for the pitch, because another recent survey by the Consumer Reports’ National Research Center revealed that three-quarters of HDTV buyers said the retailer pushed an extended warranty.
LCD AND PLASMA TVS
CR reports that the overall repair rate for the flat-panel brands was 3 percent, with little difference between LCD and plasma TVs. Among LCDs, Dell, which recently stopped selling its own brand of TVs, and Hitachi were among the less reliable brands, as were Philips plasma TVs. The reliability of Olevia and Sanyo LCD sets and Hitachi plasma TVs looks promising, though CR did not have enough historical data to list the frequency-of-repair charts.
Among the tiny percentage of sets with problems, most repairs were free, presumably because they were covered by the standard manufacturer’s warranty. The few respondents who paid out of pocket for repairs spent an average of $264 on LCD sets and $395 on plasma sets.
REAR-PROJECTION TVS
CR found that the overall repair rate for microdisplay sets using DLP and LCD rear-projection technologies was 18 percent. Toshiba and RCA DLP sets stood out as the most repair-prone. Hitachi LCD-based sets were more repair-prone than Sony and Panasonic sets of this type.
About one-quarter of repairs involved replacing the bulb, an issue unique to rear-projection TVs. Many bulb failures occurred early in a set’s life and appeared to have been covered by a standard warranty. Respondents who paid for any repairs out of pocket spent $300 on average.
The repair rate for rear-projection TVs included sets covered by an extended warranty, about 40 percent of those CR surveyed. For LCD and plasma sets, repairs under extended warranties, which are much less prevalent, were excluded. But even excluding extended-warranty repairs for rear-projection sets, they’re about three times more likely to need repair than flat-panel LCD and plasma TVs.
Even though rear-projection sets have had a higher repair rate than flat panels, most rear-projection sets proved to be trouble-free for their first few years. Many of those that did need repair were covered by a standard warranty.
