Unpaid bills hurt medical profession
That’s exactly the situation River Park Hospital CEO John McLain faces, and he’s by no means alone. Unpaid medical bills are a nationwide epidemic and there’s no clear-cut solution in sight.
At Nashville-based HCA, the hospital chain projected 10.9 percent of its total billings would end up as bad debt in 2007. For this year’s first three quarters, the actual figure has been 11.1 percent.
While River Park is no longer owned by HCA, McLain says the local hospital is certainly feeling the pinch of unpaid bills, which at times feels more like a kick.
‘We have a mission to take care of you regardless of your ability to pay,’ said McLain. ‘We have to do the right thing and take care of patients. But uncompensated care is a huge problem. The bottom line is it’s a national debate and probably one that won’t get settled for several years.’
There are a number of reasons for unpaid medical bills. For starters, there’s a segment of the population that doesn’t have health insurance.
‘You have people struggling to make their car payment and their house payment,’ said McLain. ‘Health insurance often gets left out.’
Others have insurance, but are under-insured. McLain says in an effort to make ends meet on the insurance end, premiums have skyrocketed. With some policies, deductibles can be as high as $2,000 to $3,000 before the insurance company pays a dime. Often those deductibles go unpaid.
The patients who don’t pay, in turn, make the bills higher for the patients who do pay. ‘It’s almost an unwritten tax,’ said McLain.
Hospitals are not alone. Local lung specialist Dr. Eric Lang says he too battles unpaid bills. Dr. Lang says one of his patients has such a limited income, he gave her $20 during an office visit this week so she could buy food for Thanksgiving.
Dr. Lang’s office manager, Casey Wright, says there are currently 50 accounts worth $12,000, that are being handled by a collection agency. ‘We send statements and they don’t respond,’ said Wright.
Just as troubling, Wright says, are the insurance companies. She says it’s common practice for them to pay just a fraction of the total bill and doctors are left to absorb the rest.
‘They tell you what they’ll pay and they tell you to write off the rest,’ said Wright. ‘You’re usually looking at about a 50 percent return.’
Wright said one common procedure Dr. Lang performs, a bronchoscopy with a biopsy of lung tissue, has a $575 charge. She said one common insurance company pays $157.75 of that cost, and tells Dr. Lang to write off $417.25.
Local chiropractor Leland Northcutt expressed similar sentiments. He said one patient who came in last week was charged $35 for an office visit. That patient paid a $20 co-pay on the spot and the insurance company paid 66 cents. That put Northcutt’s compensation at $20.66 for a $35 office visit.
‘Dealing with the insurance companies takes more time than it used to, there’s more paperwork, and there’s less reimbursement,’ said Northcutt. ‘As bad as it might seem, insurance is a good thing. We still have the greatest system in the world.’
Northcutt says he too has felt the undertow of unpaid bills and has modified his policy as a result. Now patients have to pay at least half when services are rendered.
‘We used to treat everybody but we got in trouble doing that,’ said Northcutt. ‘The majority of people out there are honest people, but there are always those looking to take advantage of a situation.’
It’s those people, McLain says, who are also driving up the cost of health care with malpractice lawsuits, which can easily reach millions of dollars. McLain said such lawsuits are one way to protect patients against physician negligence, but he also stressed the system is ripe with abuse. Even if no settlement is awarded to the plaintiff, legal fees can be substantial.
‘I don’t want to broad brush the malpractice issue and say all cases are unwarranted because they’re not,’ said McLain. ‘But the overflow and abuse is driving up health care expenses. It stands to reason if you steal from your community grocery store, it affects prices. It’s the same way with malpractice.’

