Local roofer questions school board
Local roofer Jason Cripps had some sharp questions for the school board Thursday night after he missed a chance to bid on a project to put a new roof on Warren County High School.
The result, Cripps said, is taxpayers are having to spend about twice as much as they should for what is estimated to be about a $360,000 project.
‘I guarantee you I could have saved the county a good chunk of money,’ said Cripps, who has 29 years of roofing experience.
Rinks & Associates, the company which handles the school system’s roofing projects, has designed a roof for the high school that includes unnecessary costs, according to Cripps. He says that includes using two layers of 15-pound felt instead of just one. Cripps says there is no advantage to using the extra layer, just added expense.
Cripps also said that the cheapest shingles are being used and these are shingles which have been a disappointment in the past. While using cheap shingles, Cripps wondered why the most expensive vents were purchased.
‘Copper vents are being used and they cost 10 times the price of aluminum or galvanized steel vents,’ said Cripps. ‘You’re putting the cheapest shingle with the most expensive vents. And why would you put the same shingle back up there that you’ve had problems with in the past? Would anybody here do that with their own home’?
Richard Rinks, the owner of Rinks & Associates, said it’s his belief the problem with that type of shingle in the past is that it didn’t have proper ventilation, which he has remedied. ‘The roofs we put on are working,’ said Rinks.
After Cripps continued his questioning, Rinks said, ‘We’re glad you have all the answers. We think this will work. Maybe we should hire you as a consultant.’
‘I guarantee you I could have done a better job,’ said Cripps.
Cripps expressed other reasons for aggravation. He said he’s tried to get on a list of preferred roofers that’s been compiled by Rinks & Associates. However, Cripps said he was given the run-around by both Rinks and the school system and never had his name added to the list.
When the high school roofing project bid was announced, it only appeared in one edition of Standard, as required by law. Cripps said he missed that announcement.
‘I guess it was a one-time shot and if you missed the July 20 edition, you’re out of luck,’ said Cripps. ‘That is unless you happened to be on the list and you were notified.’
Rinks said a former secretary must have misplaced Cripps’ request to be on the list. ‘We apologize for that if we overlooked it,’ said Rinks. ‘In hindsight, he’s on our list and he’ll be on our e-mail list.’
Cripps wondered why the school system didn’t make more of an effort to use local labor, saying he knows of 14 roofers in Warren County.
‘I know half the people on this school board,’ said Cripps, ‘and probably half the people in this central office. And not one of you happened to tell me, ‘We’re bidding the high school over here. Would you be interested in bidding’?
School board member Larry Judkins said, ‘Personally I’d like to see local people get it if possible.’
Porter Roofing, which is the only local company on the Rinks & Associates list, was awarded the bid. Cripps says he has inspected the work that Porter has done thus far and reports it’s quality work. However, he says Porter is simply following the specifications provided by Rinks & Associates and it’s those specs that are the real problem, in his opinion.
‘I think it comes down to the fact they dropped the ball on this one,’ said school board member John Turner referring to Rinks & Associates. ‘No one wants to say it, so I’ll say it.’
School system maintenance director Donnie Caldwell came to the defense of Rinks & Associates.
‘This company has really designed us some good roofs in the 13 years I’ve worked with them,’ said Caldwell.
