Judge dismisses charges against Gaye Lentz
While charges remain hanging over the head of her mother, former Trustee Joy Slatton, all criminal counts were thrown out Friday against former employee Gaye Lentz in a case her attorney says was a witch hunt.
‘This was all a witch hunt perpetrated by the former DA (Dale Potter) who was desperately seeking headlines in his bid for re-election,’ said Tim Pirtle, attorney for Lentz, pointing out Potter was Lentz’s ex-husband and Slatton’s former son-in-law. ‘She is relieved that this matter is concluded but at the same time feels that she was wronged because her ex-husband was able to bring the charges in the first place.’
Lentz was charged with being paid for work prosecutors say she did not perform back in early 2001. Prosecutors pointed out pay records show Lentz continued being paid by the county months after she left her mother’s office to take a job at Nissan.
The charges were dismissed Friday night by special judge Allen Wallace after the return of the hung jury in her mother’s case. Wallace had earlier determined, in dismissing several counts against Slatton, that the statute of limitations had expired in the Lentz cases since there is a one-year statute on the misdemeanors and two- to four-year statutes on the felonies. Wallace determined the alleged wrongdoing had been uncovered by a payroll clerk back in 2001 and reported to then-County Executive Carol Hamblen and current county attorney Larry Stanley.
While the statute of limitation was the reason the charges were dropped, Pirtle said he feels his client would have been acquitted anyway.
‘Had this gone to trial, we would have presented evidence that Gaye Lentz worked part-time in the trustee’s office during the year-end rush after leaving her full-time employment and was paid by the hour for her work,’ Pirtle said. ‘And, all of this amounted to less than $1,000.’
Along with saying his client was the target of a witch hunt, Pirtle also believes the high-profile nature of the case may have caused special prosecutor Glenn Funk to not agree to the pre-trial diversion the defense had sought. A pre-trial diversion would have suspended the charges for a couple of years before they would have been thrown out.
Pirtle also pointed out Funk, a private attorney, was Potter’s hand-picked successor after Potter recused himself after the indictments were handed down due to his relationship with the defendants. Paperwork in the case showed Potter suggested Funk be appointed in an order which was signed by Circuit Court Judge Bart Stanley.
The appointment was ironic in that it would be Funk, during the final day of trial, who told the court he should have named Judge Stanley’s father, Larry Stanley, as an unindicted co-conspirator for not following up on information regarding Gaye Lentz’s alleged wrongful payments. Funk claimed the county attorney was a friend of Slatton’s who failed to act on information that wrongdoing may have occurred.
‘One would wonder why the pre-trial motion was denied when the former DA’s hand-picked successor should have known other people are granted diversions in similar cases,’ Pirtle said, pointing to a recent story in a Midstate publication in which Funk was criticized by the Franklin district attorney for allowing a diversion. ‘He worked a deal as special prosecutor down there which has since brought quite a bit of criticism from the district attorney down there.’
In the case of the Franklin incident, Funk settled the case against Stuart Lowery there after the district attorney’s administrative assistant was caught embezzling over $3,000 from the office. The DA there felt jail time would have been appropriate. It was this settlement that irked Pirtle, who noted his client should have been given the same opportunity.
In light of suggestions Potter acted in a vengeful manner to grab headlines in indicting his former wife and mother-in-law, Funk said Potter was doing his job when he was told a crime had been committed.
‘What is he supposed to do? Look the other way,’ Funk said during the Slatton trial. ‘It was reported and it was investigated as it should be.’
