City officials OK smoke-free ordinance
City officials passed the first reading of an ordinance Tuesday to ban the use of all tobacco products in McMinnville Civic Center and inside the fenced area of Gilley Pool.
The ordinance went through with some confusion and a promise to be amended before its second reading. That amendment could include banning tobacco products in the bleachers of all ballfields.
As it stands now, the ordinance would allow the use of tobacco products in designated areas outside the Civic Center, and outside the fenced area of the pool.
‘The only area designated to smoke is right there in the eating area,’ said McMinnville Parks and Recreation director Carlene Brown referring to Gilley Pool. ‘People have complained since day one about it. For the last five years it has been a huge problem.’
Moving the smoking area would have one obvious complication for pool visitors.
‘What about those with small children’? asked Alderman Billy Wood, who was informed that lifeguards are always there to monitor unattended children around the pool. ‘Ask any mama in this country and she’ll tell you that nobody can watch her child the way she watches her child.’
While aldermen began discussing this situation, Alderman Bobby Kirby added something new to the discussion when he asked if adding ballfield bleachers has been considered.
‘I’ve been asked to look at that,’ said Kirby. ‘People sit so close together. Other ballfields do that. They have no smoking in the stands. Can we amend this’?
Just before getting a second vote to amend the ordinance that would include bleacher areas at the baseball, softball and soccer fields, concession stands at these areas were brought up since the concessions at the pool are included. There is a slight difference between the two, aldermen say.
Gilley Pool eaters and smokers are required to sit together. At ballfield concession stands, they get to move freely away from each other. However, when the tobacco area is moved outside the pool, the only thing separating the two will be a fence ‘ not much of a smoke barrier.
‘I don’t think a fence will be much of a barrier,’ said Wood who then made the motion to table the ‘whole shabangerang’ stating there are just too many questions that need to be answered before a decision could be made. Alderman Rick Barnes added a second to the motion.
With confusion high, and a motion to amend on the floor, the motion to table the amendment passed with a 5-1 vote with Alderman Patti Nunley voting against it.
Once back to the main tobacco-free issue, Kirby made a motion to table the original ordinance which brought a round of laughter from aldermen and onlookers.
‘If we vote on this ordinance now, it can be amended before the second reading,’ said Nunley, ‘which gives us some time to look at it, study it, and get all this stuff in there. When you start tabling, you are just delaying it for two weeks.’
Despite voicing a desire to withdraw his motion to table the ordinance, Robert’s Rules of Order requires the motion to come to a vote after receiving a second. The vote to table the ordinance failed with five aldermen voting against and Wood smiling as he abstained, which drew more laughter.
Back to the main motion, which was to accept the ordinance as presented, officials voted in favor of it, 5-1, with Wood voting against it. Between now and the second reading, the ordinance is expected to be changed to include the areas in which officials voiced concerns.
