Skip to content

Winkler DA needs muzzle

There’s an interview with District Attorney Michael Dunavant that’s been making the rounds this week. For those who may not know the name, Dunavant was the prosecutor in the Mary Winkler murder trial.

He may not seem so familiar because Dunavant was hardly a fixture at the trial. His assistant district attorney, Walt Freeland, did all the questioning because, it was explained, that Dunavant was only elected eight months earlier and lacked experience as a prosecutor.

Now six months removed from what will most likely be the highest profile defeat of his legal career, Dunavant has let it all air out during an in-depth interview with The Jackson Sun. In the interview, Dunavant reveals he was threatened during trial ‘ by a McMinnville resident no less ‘ who had been watching the case and was upset by the obvious poor showing by prosecutors.

Dunavant indicated the man’s phone call was traced and TBI agents were sent to his home, although he declined to give the man’s identity. He was not arrested but he was given a restraining order and told to have no further contact with prosecutors, nor travel near the trial location in McNairy County.

In hindsight, TBI agents and the state of Tennessee may have been better served to give the disgruntled man directions. Prosecutors were woefully overpowered by an all-star defense team and the verdict reflected that point.

So now we have Dunavant crying in his soup, making all sorts of comments in his recent interview about how defense attorneys basically made up their entire case, and how Winkler told wild stories on the witness stand that no one could refute.

Now it’s really clear why the state didn’t land a first-degree murder conviction. It took Dunavant six months to figure out what the rest of us knew coming in.

Dunavant went on to say he believes Winkler intended to kill herself and her children when she fled to the beach. He pointed out Mary didn’t bother to bring much money or a change of clothes, but she did bring the murder weapon and some extra shotgun shells.

In response, one of Winkler’s defense attorneys, Steve Farese Sr., said Dunavant’s comments were unethical and unprofessional. And he wondered out loud why in the world he would be saying such things now.

When it comes to Farese and this murder trial, I categorically disagree with virtually every word that has come from his mouth. I never found Winkler’s defense, or her testimony, the least bit convincing and I firmly believe she should be in prison right now.

However, Farese is 100 percent accurate when it comes to his comments on Dunavant. The case is over. It’s been long over. At this point, Dunavant has no business airing his grievances in public.

If Dunavant so desired, those would have been appropriate comments immediately after the verdict was rendered. But giving an extensive interview months later and taking swipes at the defense is counterproductive. It makes him look even more the fool.

All this goes to show the importance of electing a district attorney that’s competent and effective. While it might be cool to elect your buddy to the county commission, and it might seem neat to vote in your old pal as county clerk, the district attorney’s office is an entirely different animal.

The district attorney is the top law enforcement officer in the district ‘ period. A skillful DA can go toe-to-toe with defense attorneys and ensure criminals get put in jail. A weak district attorney means criminals go free.

Maybe next time Dunavant will discover it’s best to air his theories during the trial itself, not six months after the fact. But I know at least one person who is extremely pleased he had to learn the hard way.

James Clark is editor of the Standard. He can be reached at 473-2191.

Leave a Comment