Skip to content

Public vs. private debate begins again

The talk has started again. It’s generally heard in six of Class 1A’s eight regions where private schools compete. Discontent spreads to the other two regions once the playoffs begin. In certain geographic areas of the state where 2A and 3A teams are found, the same rumblings are heard with the emotions getting stronger as the season rolls along.

The talk I’m speaking about deals with the public vs. private competition in the athletic arena. Complaints are generally not heard much on 4A and 5A campuses in Tennessee, but only because private schools do not field football teams in these two classifications. The bigger private schools have already been moved to Division II.

But the public vs. private issue that has been a constant sore spot in Tennessee for several years will likely remain a hot topic until a total split becomes a reality. My guess is that the total split so many public school officials want to see will soon happen. Folks on the public school side of the issue just don’t feel like the playing field is level.

They may have a good argument, especially when you consider the fact that many of the football teams representing private schools are made up of players from multiple school districts and often times multiple counties. Public schools, for the most part, must field teams with players who live in a specific school zone.

Six of the 32 schools that gained playoff status in 1A this year are private in nature. Half of the six survived first round play. 2A has produced the same numbers this year. Six 2A private schools qualified for post season play and three are awaiting second round action this week.

3A football has fewer entries in the playoffs but Knoxville Catholic and David Lipscomb are heavy favorites to still be playing the second weekend in December here in Murfreesboro.

Officials at TSSAA have tried to even the playing field with legislation. They first attempted to fix the problem just over a decade ago when they created Division II, a league for private schools that award financial aid to students for both athletic and academic purposes.

The move was initially looked upon as a positive step to level the playing field between athletic teams from public and private schools. But there are still more private school competing in Division I than in Division II. This plan didn’t change things much.

Another plan was subsequently put into place. It multiplied enrollments of private schools still competing in Division I by a factor of 1.8. The end result forced many of these schools into a higher classification but also had little effect on the dominance private schools have had in gaining championship game status.

Schools will be reclassified next year for a new four-year period that will begin in 2009. New regions will be drawn and several teams will find themselves playing in new classifications.

My guess is that all private schools will be moved to Division II at that time. The move will likely satisfy numerous public school officials all across the state. But moving more than two dozen schools out of Division I will severely alter where lines are drawn between classifications. The private schools may be eliminated. But some public schools will find themselves playing in a higher classification, too.

”

Murphy Fair has published ‘Tennessee High School Football’ for the past 20 years. His Website (murphyfair.com) gives high school fans further insight into the prep football scene.

Leave a Comment