Skip to content

Slatton takes stand

Slatton takes stand

Special prosecutor Glenn Funk questions Slatton during cross examination Thursday.
Former Trustee Joy Slatton took the witness stand on Thursday and testified that her daughter, Rene Brown, was a faithful employee who rarely missed work ‘ even during serious cancer treatments.

However special prosecutor Glenn Funk painted an entirely different picture during cross examination, claiming Brown in fact missed weeks and months at a time, but never missed a paycheck.

It will be up to the jury to determine which version of events to believe as Slatton is charged with theft for allowing Brown to be paid an estimated $64,000 for time she allegedly did not work.

‘I’ve never committed a crime,’ said Slatton when her defense attorney, Michael Galligan, asked her about alleged wrongdoing. ‘I know I did the right things.’

Slatton said she was so concerned with doing what was right, she was prepared to terminate her daughter’s employment even when she was gravely ill.

‘She asked me on three separate occasions how much sick leave she had left,’ said Slatton. ‘I told her when your days run out, I’ll give you your pink slip and go down and close out your employment.’

Slatton didn’t exude the same confidence during cross examination and offered several vague explanations when asked specifically about time Brown may have missed. She didn’t want to answer a question asking her to estimate how many entire weeks Brown missed at a time. Funk grew tired of all the uncertain responses.

‘You’ve known about your case for the past 18 months,’ said Funk. ‘In all the time you’ve had to think and consult with your attorneys, you’re telling me the first you’ve thought about the time Rene missed work is right now in the middle of your trial during cross examination.’

Slatton talked about the time Brown was first diagnosed with cancer in July 2001 and how she endured heavy-duty treatments until the cancer went into remission by Christmas of that year. Despite chemotherapy and radiation treatments, Slatton said Brown rarely missed work.

‘She couldn’t wait to get there,’ said Slatton. ‘She would come in all smiles. I don’t know if it was her way of dealing with the cancer but she was always bubbly.’

Slatton said her daughter’s cancer went into remission from Christmas 2001 until March 2005 when a regular scan revealed the cancer had returned.

During the years the cancer was in remission, Slatton said Brown was energetic and eager to work. There were no signs she had battled cancer, Slatton testified.

‘People would come in the office and say, ‘I thought you were sick,’ said Slatton. She went on to say Brown took aerobics classes, went hiking and went on vacations.

Under cross examination, Slatton said that even during remission Brown missed every Tuesday for doctor’s appointments. Funk questioned why someone would need to miss a day every week when regular scans and appointments for someone in remission would likely be only every three to six months.

Asked about her connection to former District Attorney Dale Potter, who initiated the charges against her, Slatton said he is her former son-in-law. Asked if they had a good relationship, Slatton said, ‘No, it wasn’t good at all.’

The defense tried to portray the charges against Slatton as a witch hunt that was started by one of her disgruntled employees, Donna Pelham, who earlier testified against Slatton.

‘Every day that Donna Pelham worked for me was a bad day,’ said Slatton, who said Pelham didn’t listen, do work in a timely fashion, and took frequent breaks that lasted for hours.

Slatton also questioned Pelham’s integrity.

‘Donna, she has a problem with telling the truth,’ Slatton testified.

Galligan said Pelham would have an interest in making Slatton look bad because she was trying to be elected trustee. Even though Slatton wasn’t seeking re-election, if she stepped down before the end of her term, there could be a chance Pelham would be appointed, which could be an advantage at election time, Galligan said.

Funk was more concerned with time Brown was paid and wasn’t at work. Essentially, Slatton said she didn’t have a close estimate.

‘I don’t have my payroll records,’ said Slatton, who indicated the records were taken without her consent. ‘At 66, my memory is not what it used to be. I can’t honestly tell you, and I’m not going to lie about it.’

After Slatton’s testimony, three members of her office, who are still employed there, took the stand. Sharon Hillis, a cousin of Slatton’s, Holly Hillis, and Sheila Austin testified Brown missed somewhere between 400 and 600 days from 2001 until the time of her death.

However, the three, on cross examination from Galligan, said they felt pressured by Funk to set a firm number to Brown’s absences when essentially they were just guessing.

Leave a Comment