Skip to content

Trying Slatton is like trying Santa

Just as I believed coming in to the Joy Slatton trial, it may all come down to whether jurors believe the former trustee’s late daughter, Rene Brown, had sick time coming to her.

Slatton is facing multiple counts of theft for allegedly paying her daughters, Gaye Lentz, around $4,000 after she took another job, and Rene Brown, around $60,000 during time she was battling cancer.

If you’ve read the story on the trial on the front page of this issue then you know the pertinent parts of the first day of testimony. What I’m going to do is fill in the blanks since, when it all shakes out, I can only give you a small portion of everything that happens during an average day of trial due to space limitations.

First off, we had jury selection Tuesday morning. I was quite surprised we had a jury before lunch as I figured it would take all day to seat a jury.

Actually, many of those making the jury were the original people called down to take jury seats for questioning by the attorneys. After all, Slatton served seven terms as trustee and was often re-elected by large margins. I even heard one person say that trying Joy in Warren County would be like trying Santa Claus given her popularity.

As for the jury, it may surprise you that there are several people with county connections on the panel. There are at least two teachers plus the mother of a former county commissioner and the wife of a current county commissioner. There are also a couple of jurors who have served as jurors on other major criminal cases during this current jury term.

Of course, these are all facts the prosecution and defense know so they should not be an issue. And, given the fact the county has hundreds of employees, it would be hard to find 14 people without some kind of connection to county government.

By the way, there are two alternates as only 12 will decide the case. In most instances, the judge will draw two names out of the hat at the end and dismiss them. In that way, everyone will listen as if they are jurors since they won’t know who will be the actual deliberation room until the end.

Judge Allen W. Wallace is a retired judge who got the assignment as special judge when Judge Bart Stanley recused himself. He seems to be very experienced and was even forgiving of a busy reporter who addressed him as Judge Ashe this morning.

Sorry judge, just back from vacation. My brain is still in Daytona (which may I add was unseasonably cool last week).

Who is winning after the first day? No one. This case will be more complicated than most. There were times I could feel the Sandman starting to visit as they discussed time cards and accounting practices and this was just during a half day of trial. However, I don’t think this information will be the nuts and bolts of the case, but the overall belief by jurors as to whether our former trustee intended to do something wrong.

With that in mind, and given the fact the public trusted her enough to re-elect her seven times, I believe prosecutors may need a little extra evidence to get a conviction. While it may not necessitate a smoking gun to bring a conviction, it will take a substantial amount as I doubt even Santa could get elected to seven consecutive terms to anything in Warren County.

Duane Sherrill is a reporter for the Standard. He can be reached at 473-2191 or by e-mail at [email protected].

Leave a Comment