Skip to content

Soldiers and talk radio hosts

Summon the engravers and hang out flags. It’s time to retire the trophy. Absolute perfection in the art of right-wing media commentary has been achieved. Asked on NPR’s “Diane Rehm Show” about Bush administration appointees at FEMA staging a fake press conference to tout the agency’s handling of the Southern California wildfires — employees masquerading as reporters, posing scripted questions — Weekly Standard associate editor Matthew Continetti actually blamed (drum roll, please) “big government.”

Continetti said he couldn’t defend make-believe news, a major concession for a defender of the Bush administration, which has produced fake TV news stories, given payola to newspaper columnists, even supplied White House press passes to a male “escort” moonlighting as a conservative reporter. Continetti loftily explained that when you have “billions of dollars sloshing around these bureaucracies, whose only job is to promote the policies that they have designed, you’re probably likely to have these types of materials that could be likened to propaganda.”

But Continetti accomplishes two things: He remains on message, blaming the Bush administration’s epic incompetence on government itself, not Republican cronyism and corruption; and he stays inside the closed circle of GOP journalist/pundits, where critical thinking is anathema when the party’s welfare is involved. Better to say something downright laughable — Continetti’s remark almost sent me careening off the road into a cow pasture — than to court disloyalty.

For better and worse, Democrats have nothing quite like it, no phalanx of loyalists prepared to endorse any absurdity in the interest of solidarity. Democrats bicker. They’re famous for circular firing squads.

At the extremes, GOP propagandists resemble cult leaders. Consider Rush Limbaugh, the AM radio bloviator capable of generating a veritable avalanche of e-mails, letters and calls from supporters infuriated with this column for the sin of accurately characterizing inflammatory remarks Limbaugh found it convenient to deny.

The controversy is of little intrinsic import. After hanging up on a caller who described himself as a Republican Iraq veteran who urged immediate withdrawal, Limbaugh talked with a second self-described soldier. (You never know whether anybody is who they claim on talk radio or online.) The two agreed that only “phony soldiers,” Limbaugh’s words, advocated ending the war.

When called out by the indefatigable MediaMatters.org, Limbaugh started faking. He denied characterizing war critics as “phony soldiers,” posted edited transcripts on his Web site, and played edited tapes on his show.

Maybe it was Gen. Wesley Clark’s observation to the effect that anybody seeking to politicize the military didn’t belong on Armed Forces Radio. But Limbaugh lost it. He posted a photo of Stalin wearing a MediaMatters logo; he likened a wounded Iraq veteran who appeared in a TV ad challenging him to make the “phony soldier” remark to his face to a suicide bomber, “strapping those lies to his belt … to walk into as many people as he can walk into.”

Limbaugh pitched an on-air hissy fit, likening Rep. John Murtha, D-Pa., a former Marine who was awarded the Bronze Star and two Purple Hearts in Vietnam, to the braggart MacBeth. Phony soldiers all.

Who cares if Limbaugh apologizes? The point is he’s a liar. A tough lesson for cultists, I know. But for this country to regain its footing, a degree of intellectual honesty isn’t merely possible for political partisans. It’s essential.

Arkansas Democrat-Gazette columnist Gene Lyons can be reached at [email protected].

Leave a Comment