Historic city hall should not be demolished, Killebrew says
|
Thursday night’s public meeting attracted someone who is ‘mad’ about city hall in two meanings of the word. In their 10-year plan, McMinnville officials have talked about destroying the current city hall, the Blue Building, and constructing a new facility to house city government offices and the police station.
When it comes to showing strong liking or enthusiasm, Rachel Killebrew is mad about city hall. It’s the structure itself she wants to preserve. She attended first through eighth grades within the walls of the building and doesn’t want to see it torn down.
‘This is really one of the most historic buildings we have in town,’ said Killebrew. ‘It was originally a home. It was a gorgeous mansion. It’s a beautiful building.’
Although age has taken its toll, Killebrew feels the building is salvageable. To prove her point, she toured the building with Cookeville architect Peter Metz last week. According to her, his estimate matches that of the city. It will take at least $100 a square foot to restore the building.
The city began discussing renovations in 1993. In the city’s current 10-year plan, the renovation estimate includes $6 million for remodeling the 62,000-square-foot building, or $3 million for constructing a 15,000-square-foot building, $2 million for a 10,000-square-foot police station, $3 million for demolition, and $2.5 million for a Blue Memorial Park and Amphitheater.
It’s the demolition plans that have Killebrew feeling a different kind of mad. She’s angry the long-term plans include tearing it down.
‘For the last 20 years, or since I’ve been home, I’ve been trying so hard to get people to change their attitude about property management,’ said Killebrew. ‘When you use a building you have a responsibility to maintain that building and enhance it over a period of time. It is that use-it-and-then-throw-it-away attitude that I thought we were changing. I want the city to be the leaders in that change. If they go along with tearing this down, that pretty much does that in.’
Within eyeshot of the historic district, where people are asked to take care of and renovate their buildings, Killebrew questions how the city can justify tearing down one of its oldest buildings.
‘We are asking people downtown to restore their buildings,’ said Killebrew. ‘How are we going to do that and tear down one of our most historic buildings. That doesn’t make much sense. We will never get people downtown to start taking care of their buildings if the city doesn’t.’
Some suggestions included the following:
‘ Develop a 10-year plan for the Blue Building with the first two to three years devoted to getting it back in good condition so it is not continuing to deteriorate and then enhancing it over the next five to 10 years.
‘ Remove the 20,000-square-foot gymnasium from renovation costs. Removing it, because it has no architectural significance, would subtract $2 million from renovation costs.
‘ Once the gymnasium cost is removed, add the $2.5 million amphitheater behind city hall.
‘This building is worth saving,’ said Killebrew. ‘When they tore the Sedberry Hotel down, I said the next building they want to tear down they will have to run over me with a bulldozer. I told (city administrator) David Rutherford I would be laying on the steps when the bulldozer comes.’
As far as other capital improvements and establishing a 10-year plan is concerned, the reaction seems positive.
Officials are scheduled to discuss the plans for city hall, as well as all the other capital projects, Nov. 3. from 8 a.m. to 2 p.m.

