UT appeals judgment in student attack
Peter Foley, UT deputy general counsel, argued Wednesday before the state Court of Appeals that the university had no duty to protect then-18-year-old Jessica Smith from being attacked while walking from her car in a UT parking garage to her residence hall around 10:30 at night.
Tennessee Claims Commissioner Vance Cheek Jr. ruled in 2006 that UT failed to provide adequate lighting and initially awarded her $1.5 million, then reduced that to $1.25 million by assessing some blame to Smith for not paying attention to her surroundings.
The award ultimately was reduced to $300,000. Still, UT appealed the ruling and lost by a 2-1 decision of the full three-member Claims Commission.
“We’re saying no one can say if the lighting had been any different, the attack would not have occurred,” Foley told the appeals judges.
At one point, Foley argued UT had no duty to protect its 25,000 students in Knoxville.
Then, Appeals Judge Sharon G. Lee said, “Why do you have security at all?”
Appeals Judge Michael Swiney added, “If the Claims Commission found there was a dangerous condition on the property and the defect led to the crime, what else is there to find?”
