Second chances are too common
Sure, I don’t mind giving people a second chance after a mistake but it seems we’re going overboard nowadays since folks have discovered their mulligan, their do-over, their get-out-of-jail-free card which we call a diversion.
The law says if a person hasn’t been convicted of a Class B or greater felony (that’s stuff like murder, rape, armed robbery) and he or she has not served jail time, then they shall be granted a diversion upon application unless the court or prosecutor can cite good cause why they should not be granted the diversion.
There are two kinds of diversions. The first is a pre-trial diversion which is granted by the prosecutor where the charges are suspended for two years and, provided there is no trouble, then the charges are forgotten. The next is a judicial diversion awarded by the court, where the person enters a plea, but, if there is no further legal trouble during the probationary period then their record is erased.
First off, let me just say that a pre-trial diversion is a useless piece of law and should be done away with. It is pure and simple a bit of wiggle room put into the law to keep defendants from facing the music. If you’re going to grant a pre-trial diversion, then just drop the charges because that would have the same effect. The way I look at it, if it’s a felony case and a grand jury has indicted, then suspending those charges without a jury getting a chance to hear them is going counter to the American legal system.
Now I don’t have as big a problem with a judicial diversion since the person has to enter a plea, meaning, any further trouble and they face serving the whole time behind bars (just like violating probation) since their plea is on the books. At least in a judicial diversion you are making the person admit they did something wrong and holding them accountable. A pre-trial diversion is simply giving them a free pass.
The one problem I do have with judicial diversions is they are too widely used. Really, the only people who can’t get them are murderers, rapists and armed robbers. This means arsonists, persons who beat someone within an inch of their lives (aggravated assault) and grand larcenists (people who clean you out for tens of thousands of dollars) are all eligible.
What I wish would happen is that the legislature would tighten up the offenses for which a person can get a diversion. I don’t think any crime involving bodily injury to another person should qualify under judicial diversion, nor should any crime which causes substantial risk to the life of another like risking firemen with arson, racing away from police in felony evading and firing a gun in a crowd as in felony reckless endangerment.
And, I prefer to see the word ‘shall’ taken out of the code to allow a judge to decide, by the majority of the evidence, as to whether the person should be allowed the diversion. Judges, at least around here, are usually a good enough judge of character to decide who is deserving of a judicial diversion.
What if it were you, Duane? Well, first off, if it were me and I was looking at a diversion, then that’d mean I’d committed a crime since I’m not agreeing to plea to something I didn’t do. I get what I get at that point.
Bottom line is we need to get rid of the sham we call a pre-trial diversion and sure up the judicial diversion law so we aren’t giving free passes to folks who are beginning their lives of criminal behavior.
Duane Sherrill is a reporter for the Standard. He can be reached at 473-2191 or by e-mail at [email protected].
