Skip to content

State wrong to keep secrets about cigarette smuggling

Under Tennessee law, it’s a misdemeanor to possess more than 20 packs ‘ two cartons ‘ of cigarettes that don’t have Tennessee tax stamps. Anyone bringing in more than 25 cartons can be charged with a felony.

This apparently wasn’t much of an issue until smokers started crossing the state line to buy cigarettes and dodge the sales tax, which had increased from 20 cents to 62 cents in July.

That’s when the state Department of Revenue said it intensified the enforcement along the border with 10 revenue officers involved in the program.

So, how has it been going? How many cartons have been seized? How many people have been arrested?

Those are all good questions, but the people of Tennessee are being kept in the dark on the answers.

The department has refused to grant an Associated Press information request on how widespread the enforcement has been. The justification was there were concerns about violating taxpayer confidentiality. A spokeswoman said the department would be more comfortable with releasing data in a few months.

The excuse that people’s personal information would be made public is unacceptable. Statistics unattached to identification could be released without compromising anyone’s right to privacy under the law. Of course, once someone has been charged with a crime, he usually doesn’t have much privacy left.

At any rate, when a government entity refuses to release information that the public has every right to see and evaluate, it looks as though it is trying to hide something, whether it really is or not.

Full disclosure is the best policy and one the citizens of this state expect from their government.

Leave a Comment