Skip to content

WWE should take lessons from TNA

Don’t tell Vince McMahon this since he might have me liquidated for my insolence, but Wrestlemania was topped Sunday night by TNA’s Bound for Glory pay-per-view as the secondary brand overcame its recent reputation as the home for washed up WWE superstars to put on the show of the year.

For those who aren’t up to speed on TNA, it’s the wrestling in the six-sided ring which can be seen on Spike TV at 8 p.m. on Thursday nights. It was started by Jeff Jarrett several years ago, first taping its shows in Nashville before moving to Universal Studios in Orlando where TNA does most of its tapings.

It should also be noted TNA has just gone to a two-hour show, thereby allowing promoters more time for character development and actual wrestling action. Prior to this month and the increase in time, there was barely enough time to follow the main story, let alone the mid-card storylines where many wrestlers would be left completely off TNA programming for a month or two because there was no time.

However, even when there was less time, TNA has generally packed in as much wrestling action as WWE does in a two-hour show. And, that’s what a lot of us fans want, less talk and more action.

It was the wrestling action which set Bound for Glory, which is TNA’s biggest show of the year, its version of Wrestlemania if you will, apart from its WWE counterpart.

There wasn’t really a soft spot to the three-hour show which culminated with Sting defeating Kurt Angle for the TNA championship in a well-booked match which saw Kevin Nash basically cost the Olympic Hero the title. Oh, it’s true, it’s true.

So why is it that a lower budget brand like TNA can better the original pay-per-view king Vince McMahon, basically beating him at the game he invented?

I think there are three reasons. First, TNA stands for Total Nonstop Action, the last word in their name standing for something that’s lacking in wrestling today. While inventing the wrestling business as we know it, transforming regional wrestling alliances into a worldwide business, McMahon has forgotten that this is sports entertainment, not a prime-time soap opera.

In the old days, original stars like Ric Flair, Harley Race and Dusty Rhodes thought nothing of battling an hour in the ring, keeping the fans interested for 60 full minutes. Nowadays, we’re lucky to get 10 minutes out of a match, and that match is generally interrupted by a commercial. Then we get treated to a McMahon tirade or some slow-paced slapstick skit backstage that amounts to nothing more than providing us time to go the refrigerator for a snack.

The second reason TNA is outperforming WWE is its roster is thicker from top to bottom. Despite having a much higher payroll, WWE is really lean on top-level performers. We basically have six stars on RAW and four on Smackdown. And as for ECW, maybe C.M. Punk.

Meanwhile, TNA has a wealth of top performers with even those who aren’t in the title chase still set up as legitimate stars. This is why TNA was able to have a top to bottom classic show at Bound for Glory without having to recycle feuds that we’ve seen a hundred times already (if you don’t count Robert Roode and Eric Young in the finals of the battle royal at BFG).

The final reason that TNA’s product is better is that they wrestle far less than WWE. The regular schedule for WWE performers is four days on, three days off. Granted, they may just work 15 minutes a night but there’s still travel in between shows which can be more taxing than the actual performance.

On the other hand, TNA tapes most of its shows in Orlando, sometimes doing two or three shows at once. This means the TNA wrestlers are fresher and their bodies rested so they can do more the high-flying stunts which are so entertaining, not having to worry about being on the road the next three nights after a pay-per-view.

But, the bottom line, six out of six people at my PPV gathering this week, all of whom saw Wrestlemania with me this year, agreed Bound for Glory was the superior show of the two. Good news for TNA, bad news for McMahon.

Leave a Comment