Skip to content

Majority of offenders get second chance

Majority of offenders get second chance

STANLEY
When a convicted drug dealer walks away from a courtroom without having to serve a day in jail, it may appear local prosecutors and judges are going too lightly on crime.

That’s not the case. What they’re doing is going by Tennessee law, which essentially gives people one get-out-of-jail card, provided the crime wasn’t too severe.

‘Judges don’t want to come off as soft, but we have to follow the law,’ said Circuit Court Judge Bart Stanley. ‘I have mixed feelings about it. In some instances when a young person does something stupid, you hate to see a felony on their record that prevents them from getting a decent job for the rest of their life. The other argument is if you get a felony it lessens the offense if you don’t get a stiff punishment for it.’

Tennessee law allows defendants to seek either a pre-trial diversion or a judicial diversion, provided they meet certain guidelines. Both diversions allow the defendant to have the charges either dismissed or erased from their record, provided they don’t get into further trouble during a probationary period.

Since there remains a good deal of confusion about these two diversions, the Standard will explain how each works.

Pre-trial diversion

As its name suggests, the pre-trial diversion takes place before a potential trial which means the person does not have to enter a plea. Instead, they enter into a memorandum of understanding which states prosecution will be suspended for a period not to exceed two years.

Pre-trial diversions are handled through the district attorney’s office.

‘Under the law, if they qualify and they apply, we have to consider it,’ said District Attorney Lisa Zavogiannis. ‘The way the law is written, it’s almost as if they are entitled to it if they meet the qualifications. If we don’t want to grant it, we have to state our reasons for opposing it.’

To qualify, a defendant cannot have been granted a previous pre-trial diversion and the offense cannot be a Class A or Class B felony. Most sexual and violent offenses are also excluded, and a person accused of driving under the influence can’t apply for a pre-trial diversion.

If a person is granted a pre-trial diversion, they have to abide by a number of requirements. This includes reporting to a probation officer, getting drug tested, participating in a treatment program and paying a fine.

‘They still have to think about what they did every month because they have to report to a probation officer,’ said Zavogiannis. ‘And they’re subject to search at any time. It can be an eye-opening experience.’

Zavogiannis says she favors the judicial diversion because it makes a person enter a plea in court. That forces a person to admit a mistake was made and it makes them take responsibility for their actions, she said.

As for her overall opinions of diversions, she said each case should be considered on an individual basis.

‘Sometimes you deserve a second chance and that’s what this is,’ said Zavogiannis. ‘You make of it what you want. Hopefully, we’ll never see these people again.’

Since defendants don’t go to trial on pre-trial diversions, if they violate the terms of the memorandum of understanding, the charges are brought up in court as a new case, and guilt or innocent would be determined at that point.

If the defendant does not violate the terms of the agreement, the prosecution drops the charges at the end of the specified time limit.

Judicial diversion

Unlike pre-trial diversions, judicial diversions are awarded at the discretion of the judge. But like pre-trial diversion, the law says judicial diversions should be granted to a ‘qualified defendant.’

Judicial diversions are handled by the judge, although the district attorney can issue a statement either approving or opposing it.

‘The majority of the time, if a person qualifies, there’s not a good reason not to give it,’ said Stanley. ‘On cases like forgery, for example, there aren’t usually extenuating circumstances where you can say this is why I deny it.’

Before a judicial diversion can be granted, a defendant has to enter a guilty plea, or no-contest plea, which is viewed as a guilty plea in the eyes of the law. The person is then placed on probation for no longer than the maximum sentence for which they are charged.

The person has similar release requirements such as regular visits with a probation officer and drug testing. Community service work can also be required.

Defendants who successfully complete the program can petition the court for an order to expunge the charges from all official records, other than non-public records. Copies of the charges are still sent to the Tennessee Bureau of Investigation to be kept as non-public records.

Before a pre-trial or judicial diversion is granted, the defendant first has to be cleared by the TBI to ensure he or she has not received a previous diversion.

Leave a Comment