Skip to content

Victim’s family: Griffin will kill again-Wheeler hopes he receives death penalty next time

Saying she hopes her nephew’s killer gets the death penalty if he kills again, Jamie Wheeler was among the family members of the slain Chad Nunley to speak Wednesday at the sentencing of Billy Griffin, following which he walked from the courtroom a free man.

‘Lots of facts did not come out in court for jurors to hear so that makes you a lucky man right now,’ Wheeler said from the witness stand as Griffin listened stoically from the defense table. ‘But evil always follows evil and you will kill again. Maybe this is the devil’s plan for you. Hopefully, next time you kill, you will get the death sentence.’

Griffin was released on time served following his conviction in August on lesser charges of reckless endangerment and possession of a firearm. He received a two-year sentence during his appearance before Circuit Court Judge Bart Stanley Wednesday, meaning he owes no more time given his year in jail. He could have faced up to 25 years if jurors had convicted him on the top charge of second-degree murder.

Griffin fatally shot Nunley at a party on Harrison Ferry Mountain, hitting him with four rounds fired at near point-blank range from a 9mm handgun he was carrying in his friend’s vehicle. While his firing the fatal shots was never in question, the reasons he shot the man he had never known prior to the party was the main point of debate during trial.

Prosecutors maintained Griffin was looking for trouble when he made statements to Nunley following a separate altercation Nunley and his brother had with another man at the party. Prosecutors also maintained Griffin was knowingly armed and shot Nunley when there was no immediate threat to his own safety.

The defense maintained Nunley had shown his tendency for violence by ganging up on a smaller man at the party and had come down to the vehicle in which Griffin was trying to leave with the intent to start trouble. Griffin also maintained he saw a knife and that Nunley pulled open his car door and grabbed him, prompting him to fire the shots to protect himself.

While not completely acquitting him, jurors found in favor of Griffin’s story as evidenced by their verdict.

‘It really wasn’t exactly what I expected them to find,’ Judge Stanley said from the bench Wednesday concerning the verdict. ‘But they obviously found some self-defense in their verdict. It was an unusual verdict.’

Given the minor verdict against her nephew’s killer, Wheeler pointed out the pain it has caused Nunley’s family.

‘He is not only a murderer, but also a thief,’ Wheeler said. ‘He has robbed this family of Chad’s presence and any future grandchildren he may have had. Griffin, you have murdered with callous disregard for human life.’

Along with the killing, Wheeler questioned Griffin’s conduct during the course of the trial, noting Griffin and his family acted as if they were at a family reunion rather than a murder trial. She also pointed out Griffin had allegedly smiled at the victim’s mother while he was being led from the courtroom during proceedings.

‘Your family will always make excuses for you,’ Wheeler said. ‘You will have to stand before God one day, and that’s when there will be true justice.’

Wheeler, who works at Warren County Jail, said Griffin had made threats to ‘shank’ (stab with a jail-made weapon) her while he was an inmate and to ‘pop’ (slang for shoot) Nunley’s brother.

Wheeler also pointed to Griffin’s teardrop tattoo under his eye which is known to symbolize a person who has killed another person.

‘You were so proud of the fact you had murdered someone that you had a teardrop tattooed by the corner of your eye while you were in jail after you killed Chad,’ said Wheeler, noting his attorneys helped him cover up the tattoo with makeup before the trial.

In passing sentence, Judge Stanley said he hopes Griffin learned a lesson given the fact one man is dead and Griffin himself lost a year of his life behind bars.

‘I guess if there’s any lesson to be learned here it is to leave your guns at home because someone is going to end up in jail and someone is going to end up dead,’ Stanley said.

The family wants Griffin to pay over $9,000 restitution for funeral and burial expenses. Judge Stanley said he will decide on restitution in the coming week.

Leave a Comment