Frontloading stirs controversy
The current controversy over ‘frontloading’ the 2008 presidential primaries is merely the latest in a series of controversies that have surrounded the presidential nominating process for much of our nation’s history.
Early on, party bosses played a pivotal role in picking party nominees for president.??The era of ‘the smoke-filled room’ gradually gave way to national nominating conventions in the 1830s. State presidential primaries began in 1912 and are now the rule, with few exceptions. Ostensibly, this evolution in methods of picking presidential nominees was part of the larger process of giving average American citizens more say in the political decisions previously made by the few.
The question is: Have we turned the corner on democratizing the presidential nominating process or have we merely circled the block’The answer to that question depends on who you ask.
Supporters of frontloading insist it is the best way to mobilize voters and get them to participate more fully in the nomination process.??
Opponents of frontloading have now joined the battle with a fury worthy of the controversy.??For example, Sen. Lamar Alexander is touting ‘a series of regional contests’ as a viable alternative to frontloading.??He likens his legislative proposal to the NFL’s Super Bowl, where all ‘credible contenders’ have a fair chance to win.
Normally, I’m not a big fan of applying sports analogies to politics.??However, Sen. Alexander’s proposal deserves serious discussion and debate.??I do see at least two potential flaws in his proposal.??
First, unlike the Super Bowl, which is played every year, Sen. Alexander’s regional alternative would come every four years, with the four regions, East, West, Midwest and South each taking turns being first to hold their state primaries. Primaries would be held on the first Tuesdays in March, April, May and June, starting in 2012.This will be a very hard sell to the states that would then be first only every 16 years.
Second, I’m not sure Sen. Alexander’s proposal can pass Constitutional muster.?? Under our system of federalism, the Constitution allows considerable latitude to the states regarding elections, even those for president.??By inference, this includes considerable latitude in the presidential primaries and caucuses as well.
Whether Sen. Alexander’s thought-provoking regional alternative flies like an eagle or falls like a rock remains to be seen.?? Meanwhile, frontloaded primaries will be the new reality in 2008.
The biggest fans of frontloading the presidential primaries are, of course, the frontrunners, like Hillary and Rudy, for now. Why’Because frontloading favors those who have the money and the momentum to exploit their relative advantages on ‘Super-duper Tuesday.’??
The biggest foes of frontloading the presidential primaries are, predictably, the second- and third-tier candidates, who are likely to fall prey to the ‘thinning of the herd’ by early February, 2008.
Ultimately, though, ‘We the people’ will decide the outcomes of the presidential primaries, limited though our choices may be.??If frontloading increases voter turnout, that’s good.??If not, we can always consider alternatives for 2012 and beyond, including Senator Alexander’s regional plan.
Thomas B. Vaughn is an instructor at Motlow College and co-host of ‘Viewpoints,’ which airs on WCPI 91.3 FM.
