Skip to content

Witness tells of deadly showdown – Hale was shot first, defense says

Witness tells of deadly showdown - Hale was shot first, defense says

TBI forensic pathologist Dr. Thomas Deering points to the areas where John Scott was hit by rounds from a 44 Magnum fired by Joe Hale during a gunfight between the two. Scott died after a major artery was hit, causing him to bleed to death.
Caught in the middle of a furious gunfight which left a Van Buren County commissioner dead and his accused killer seriously wounded, the lone eyewitness to the deadly showdown testified Tuesday, saying it was the elected official who fired the first shot.

‘He shot me in the gut,’ witness Richard Cope recalled accused murderer Joe Hale saying as he fell to the ground, clutching his stomach after being struck by a 9mm round fired by Van Buren County Commissioner John Scott on the afternoon of May 18, 2004 in the parking lot of Parkway Southside Market.

Cope testified that he saw Hale struggle back to his nearby vehicle where he retrieved his own gun, a 44 Magnum, and took aim at the man who had just shot him.

‘John opened up (shooting again) when he saw the big guy (Hale) with the gun,’ said Cope. ‘After it was over, John told me ‘They got me. They got me real good, Rick.’

Those were the last words he heard Scott utter as he later died at Erlanger Medical Center from complications to his wounds which forensic pathologist Dr. Thomas Deering would testify was brought on by massive blood loss caused when at least two of the rounds, both passing through his SUV door and striking him in the leg, hit his femoral artery.

‘When I opened the door, blood was just pouring out of the vehicle,’ recalled market owner Winton Humble, who had yelled at his family inside to get down when gunfire erupted outside. ‘John still had the pistol in his hand so I took it. He wasn’t able to speak.’

In the meantime, Jason Smith sped from the scene of the shooting, his passenger (Hale) passing out from loss of blood from his stomach wound.

‘I told him he had messed up,’ Smith recalled telling Hale of the gunfight.

Smith, who was originally charged with first-degree murder along with Hale, said they were at the store by mere coincidence when Hale and Scott had a confrontation at Scott’s vehicle.

‘I saw him (Hale) hit the ground after he’d been shot,’ Smith recalled of the incident after revealing prosecutors had dismissed all charges against him without any sort of deal for his cooperation. ‘I got out and then I saw the gun pointed in my direction. I tried to get the truck started but the fly wheel was messing up.’

Smith said he did not even realize his friend had leaned out the window and returned fire on Scott because his ears were still ringing from Scott’s gunfire. Smith also said he did not know Hale had a gun with him, although Hale had a carry permit.

While Smith maintained the encounter was coincidence, special prosecutor Tommy Thompson, who was given the case after DA Lisa Zavogiannis recused herself due to potential conflict of interest, believes there was more than a chance encounter. Specifically, prosecutors are pointing to an incident, earlier that day, in which local auto parts dealer, and Hale friend, Robert Hastings was beaten up by Scott.

‘He called me to come see him, I thought to maybe pay what he owed, and then he just turned and hit me,’ said Hastings, who was well older than Scott. Hastings said he took an assault warrant on Scott and warned his sons not to go around him. ‘He threatened to kill me.’

Prosecutors suggest Hale was mad because the ‘younger man had jumped the older man’ and that he was looking for trouble when he confronted Scott. Cope said Scott appeared nervous at the market when he saw Smith and Hale pull into the parking lot, noting Scott had left his driver’s door open when he went in to pay for his gas. Randal Mealer earlier testified he had seen Smith do a U-turn on Highway 111 to get in behind Scott just before the shooting.

As to what happened to cause the shooting, Smith said he saw his friend go to throw away trash at a can near where Scott was parked at the pumps. However, at some point he saw him reach into Scott’s window with his right hand, something that has puzzled both sides since Hale has no workable fingers on his right hand due to an earlier accident which severed the fingers on his right hand.

TBI analyst Shelby Betts testified at least one of the bullets passed through Scott’s driver’s window from the inside out, meaning he fired at Hale through an at least partially closed window, confirming testimony from Cope that Scott had jumped into his car and locked his door as Hale approached.

Testimony is expected to conclude this morning at the Van Buren County Courthouse in Spencer.

Leave a Comment