Skip to content

Winkler grabbed gun to tell husband to ‘relax’ – She tells Oprah that Matthew could say ‘some horrible things’

In her first interview since she was convicted of killing her preacher husband, Mary Winkler said she grabbed the shotgun used in the crime because she wanted to tell Matthew Winkler to enjoy life.

Winkler’s appearance Wednesday on ‘The Oprah Winfrey Show’ included several tough questions. Oprah asked what she planned to say to her husband with a shotgun in her hands.

‘Be happy,’ said Winkler. ‘He had to be miserable the way he acted and to just stop being so mean and to just relax and enjoy life.’

Oprah asked, ‘Why the shotgun? Why couldn’t you just say Matthew, relax, be happy, calm down, enjoy life.’

‘He never would have allowed that,’ replied Winkler. ‘I’m sitting here thinking now what I wish I could have said to him.’

Winkler paused often when answering the questions and was largely emotionless.

She acted much like she did on the witness stand, speaking in a monotone voice and rarely making eye contact. There were a couple questions Winkler didn’t answer because she said she couldn’t remember what happened.

Winkler didn’t offer much new information from what was said during trial. She dodged a question Oprah asked about physical abuse.

‘Did he hit you often’? asked Oprah.

‘All I focused on was keeping him happy and trying to help him and trying to steer clear,’ replied Winkler.

Winkler indicated her husband could say ‘some very horrible things.’ When Oprah pressed for specific things Matthew said, Winkler was vague.

‘Weight, hair, long, short, family, friends, keeping up the house, something about the girls, just very, very critical,’ she said.

Oprah asked about subjects already discussed in depth such as the wig and high heels Winkler said she was made to wear during sex, the money transfers made in the days before the killing, and the financial troubles that engulfed the family.

Oprah asked Winkler if she meant to point the gun at her husband.

‘When I heard the boom, I thought it would hit the ceiling, the window and I just thought oh my goodness, he’s going to think I meant to do that on purpose,’ said Winkler. ‘So I took out of there. I took off running and at some point I realized he wasn’t chasing me and I had to go back in there and face the music.’

Winkler said she did ask for a divorce during the nearly three years the family lived in Warren County.

‘I did ask for a divorce in McMinnville but that was not allowed,’ she said. ‘He did too and we talked about it and that was one of the few times I spoke up and said what I thought.’

Winkler said her husband threatened to cut her up in a ‘million pieces’ and had previously pointed the shotgun at her. Even with such violent behavior, Winkler said she didn’t think Matthew realized their relationship was troubled.

‘I will always grieve the fact that I failed Matthew in not bringing it to his attention how bad it was,’ said Winkler.

At one point Winkler said, ‘There are a lot of things that don’t make sense to me.’

To which Oprah replied, ‘I imagine. It doesn’t make sense to me either.’

The end of the hour-long show focused on the ongoing child custody battle. Matthew’s parents have custody of Mary’s three girls.

Oprah asked Winkler why she should get her children back.

‘I’m their mother,’ she said.

‘You killed their father,’ said Oprah.

‘I did not want any of this to happen,’ replied Winkler.

The next hearing regarding the children is scheduled for this Wednesday.

Winkler’s attorneys, Steve Farese and Leslie Ballin, were in the studio audience and answered questions at the end of the show. Ballin said he firmly believes Winkler should regain custody.

‘Not only is it legally possible, I strongly feel it should happen,’ said Ballin. ‘She needs those kids and they need her.’

Leave a Comment