Who is to blame for Chinese toy recall? – Survey says U.S. also responsible for unsafe products
With the tally of Chinese goods bearing high levels of chemicals and toxins growing almost daily, people in the survey reserved the bulk of their ire for Chinese companies. Nearly two-thirds, or 64 percent, said Chinese firms making the tainted products deserve a lot of the responsibility ‘ more than anyone else.
Even so, by a broader measure there was widespread consensus that plenty of blame can be spread on both sides of the Pacific. Eighty-four percent said Chinese manufacturers and the U.S. businesses which sell Chinese products in this country deserve some or a lot of culpability for the problem.
In addition, while 79 percent said the Chinese government bears at least some fault, a similar 75 percent said the same about the U.S. government. And 71 percent said U.S. consumers insisting on low-cost goods have at least some responsibility as well.
“If we find something for one dollar instead of $1.10, it’s like a herd instinct, we’ll all trot over there,” said Carol Mason, 59, a retired telephone company office manager in Butler, Ala. “Well, the lowest price is not always the best if you want a quality product.”
Almost two-thirds, or 65 percent, said the U.S. government is not doing enough to ensure that Chinese imports are safe. That criticism was voiced by majorities from all regions and segments of the population, though women and Democrats were likelier to feel that way.
“It’s their job to check these things,” Sean Overland, 34, a trial consultant in Los Angeles, said of federal inspection efforts. Still, he said, “It’s impossible for them to screen every single thing that comes into the country.”
The strong sense that at least some blame must be assigned to U.S. companies, consumers and the government cut a fairly even swath across most lines of income, age, race, region and education.
The poll also underscored how the drumbeat of worldwide recalls and complaints about Chinese-made toys, seafood, toothpaste and pet food has hurt that country’s chances in the lucrative U.S. market.
While 75 percent said they feel very or somewhat confident about all products they purchase, whatever their source, only 41 percent said that about items from China ‘ including just 7 percent saying they are very confident.
Chinese imports to the U.S. totaled $288 billion last year, a figure surpassed by only Canadian products. More than 60 percent of the recalls announced this year by the Consumer Product Safety Commission have involved Chinese goods, and all 40 toy recalls were in connection with products made in China.
Asked what portion of their purchases come from China, people typically said 50 percent, with half saying more than that, half less.
Peter Morici, a University of Maryland economist and former director of the U.S. International Trade Commission’s economics office, estimated that Chinese imports account for about 10 percent of U.S. purchases.
Other analysts said that figure seemed reasonable. They suggested the public’s high estimate came from the surge of news stories about Chinese imports and because that country is a major supplier of common consumer items like toys, athletic shoes and low-priced clothing.
