Skip to content

Griffin takes stand, says he could retreat no further

Saying he was scared for his life, accused murderer Billy Joe Griffin said he had retreated as far as he could when he pulled his gun and fired four shots into Chad Nunley as he was being attacked by the victim.

‘If there had been any way out of the situation without using force, I would have taken it,’ Griffin, 23, testified Tuesday as his defense got under way after the prosecution rested its case.

Griffin maintains Nunley and others followed him to the car in which he was a passenger as he was attempting to leave a keg party on Harrison Ferry Mountain last May. Griffin said he had just witnessed Nunley and others assault another party-goer, kicking him while he was down.

‘I told Daniel (the driver of the car in which he had arrived) that it was getting rowdy and let’s get out of here,’ Griffin recalled as they left the deck where they had been hanging out. ‘Nobody deserves to get jumped like that.’

While admitting he shook his head in disagreement at the victim and others beating up the man identified as James Rankhorn, Griffin said he did not recall actually saying anything to Nunley. Earlier witnesses said they heard Griffin refer to the beating of Rankhorn as ‘not being right’ with at least one witness saying the alleged comment brought Nunley and Griffin face to face on the deck, something Griffin said never happened.

Instead, Griffin testified he walked to the car but was jumped by Nunley and struck in the head. He was then prevented from closing the door by Nunley who was allegedly trying to pull him out of the vehicle.

‘I saw a knife,’ Griffin testified, saying someone behind Nunley had the weapon causing him to fear, given the beating he had just witnessed, that he would be beaten and stabbed.

Some witnesses who testified supported Griffin’s claim that he was punched by Nunley at the door of his car while other witnesses said they saw no blows thrown just before the shooting.

It was at that point Griffin said he grabbed the gun he had placed under the driver’s seat and shot Nunley at close range, striking him twice in the neck and twice in the chest.

Forensic pathologist Dr. Bruce Levy testified any one of the wounds would have proven fatal because they hit major organs. Levy also testified one of the neck shots appeared to slope sharply downward.

The state maintains it was the angle of the gun while the defense maintained it was the result of Nunley leaning into the car as Griffin said. Levy also said the close grouping of wounds suggests the shots were in rapid succession, backing up witnesses saying the shots were heard close together.

As for the 9mm itself, Griffin said he had placed the gun in his friend’s car because he did not want to leave it in his own car which he left parked in town. He said it was in his car because he had been out target shooting as he often does. Prosecutors questioned his thought process, pointing out the windows were left partially down, meaning party-goers may have been able to find the gun.

‘Have you ever heard that guns kill people,’ questioned District Attorney General Lisa Zavogiannis, to which Griffin responded, ‘No, people kill people’.

Griffin maintained he and the driver tried to call 911 from the driveway but were unable to get a signal on top of the mountain. He pointed out he later surrendered to lawmen.

While Griffin maintains he acted in self-defense, the state brought witnesses to suggest he went beyond the bounds of self-defense.

‘I saw him shoot Chad dead for no reason,’ testified Gabe Cantrell, saying he saw Griffin re-open his door himself and open fire. ‘I’m lucky I didn’t get shot myself.’

The defense also went on the attack regarding the deceased, pointing out Nunley had four convictions for reckless endangerment with a deadly weapon, aggravated assault and assault back in 1999.

Dr. Levy testified Nunley had a .19 blood alcohol content when he died, more than twice the state’s legal limit for intoxication.

Testimony resumes at 9 a.m. this morning at Warren County Courthouse. The trial is expected to conclude today.

Leave a Comment