Jury to decide: murder or self-defense – Griffin on trial for killing Chad Nunley
|
‘Billy Joe Griffin murdered Chad Nunley,’ proclaimed assistant district attorney Josh Crain in the prosecution’s opening statement Monday afternoon. ‘He ran his mouth and acted tough and murdered Mr. Nunley so he wouldn’t have to take the chance of getting a whooping.’
Griffin is on trial for second-degree murder.
In contrast to the state’s version, the defense maintains Griffin was backed into a corner, facing the possibility of several people attacking him, one who he says was wielding a knife.
‘This is a case of self-defense,’ said Griffin’s attorney, Michael Galligan. ‘Mr. Nunley was being loud, obnoxious and had been picking on people earlier.’
Neither side is denying Griffin fired four shots from a 9mm handgun at close range to inflict the fatal wounds.
The debate is whether Griffin believed he was being threatened with serious bodily injury by the actions of the deceased.
According to the prosecution, Griffin had witnessed Nunley and his brother, Tristan Nunley, beat up another person who was attending the keg party in the early morning hours of May 6 of last year. Witnesses reportedly said the beating victim, James Rankhorn, had said something antagonistic to the brothers, prompting the altercation.
At that point, prosecutors say Griffin said something about that fight, causing Nunley to turn on him. Griffin was then told to leave by one of the party hosts, something he and the driver of the vehicle in which he arrived were doing when more words were exchanged, prompting Nunley to follow them to their car.
However, Crain said his actions show Griffin was not afraid for his safety.
‘As he’s walking, yes walking, to the car, he still can’t stop running his mouth,’ said Crain, suggesting Griffin invited Nunley into continuing the altercation with him.
The incident which followed is under heated debate with prosecutors saying Griffin got into the vehicle, closed the door, then opened it again as Nunley approached, firing four shots into the victim before fleeing the scene. Other party-goers tried to stop them from leaving but were unsuccessful, according to reports.
However, Griffin maintains Nunley opened the door and punched him, noting he saw other people coming down the hill from the party causing him to think he was about to be attacked by several others. Griffin also said he saw someone with a knife.
The gun Griffin pulled, the defense says, was in his friend’s car because he had been out target shooting the day before. Griffin would later tell police he ‘had no choice’ but to shoot Nunley because of his fear he would be beaten and stabbed.
‘Mr. Nunley has been convicted of violence before,’ Galligan noted, adding the closeness of the wounds suggests Nunley was upon his client when the shots were fired.

