Witness: Soldier admitted to killing family
Sgt. Anthony Yribe, 23, was the first witness called as a court-martial entered its second day for Pfc. Jesse Spielman, who is accused of being a lookout while his colleagues attacked and killed a 14-year-old Iraqi girl and her family in March 2006. Spielman faces rape and murder charges because prosecutors allege he had prior knowledge of the crime.
Yribe’s testimony focused largely on former Pfc. Steven D. Green, who is accused of being the ringleader. Three soldiers have pleaded guilty for their roles and received sentences of five to 100 years. Green, who was discharged from the Army before being charged, will face the possibility of the death penalty when he is tried in federal court.
Yribe described the scene, as prosecutors displayed grisly photos depicting all four family members as they were found. There was a giant charred outline of the 14-year-old girl’s upper body, which had been burned to ash. Her legs and the remnants of a blue and purple dress were sticking out from the pile of ashes.
Yribe said after visiting the scene, he arrived at a checkpoint manned by Spielman and the others. He said Green and Sgt. Paul E. Cortez were waiting for him and that Green told Yribe he had attacked the family.
“I didn’t believe him at all,” Yribe said, adding that he didn’t think such an attack was possible in broad daylight in a particularly violent region. He said leaving the relative security of a military checkpoint under those circumstances was certain to bring problems.
Yribe also described Green as a lanky, thin soldier, who had had difficulty exhibiting authority or commanding respect from Iraqis while on patrol.
“He really didn’t have any authority at all,” Yribe said.
Yribe said that he pressed Green for details, including locations of the bodies and how the people had died, which Green described correctly, but Yribe said he still did not believe him. Yribe said he approached Green later and pressed harder, and Green expressed a hatred for Iraqis.
During his testimony, Yribe admitted that earlier in the investigation he had made false statements to military investigators and to his battalion commanders. He also admitted not reporting what Green had told him.
Charges against Yribe of failing to report information about the crime were not referred to court-martial, and he does not currently face charges, but he testified his admissions Tuesday were not part of an agreement with prosecutors.
Maj. Alex Pickands, an Army prosecutor, painted a picture for jurors of an undisciplined unit that had begun to unravel in a violent area of Iraq and soldiers who made decisions to do things they could have avoided.
Pickands said that as the plans were hatched to attack the family, Spielman told the others, “Hey, I’m down with that,” and they departed.
Defense lawyer Dan Christensen gave a different scene.
“Every person involved in these allegations had been diagnosed with a mental disorder by March 12th,” he said. “Their ability to cope with the situation was drinking. It wasn’t a big party down there. It was a way for them to deal with the problems they had.”
He said his client _ who pleaded guilty to conspiracy to obstructing justice, arson, wrongfully touching a corpse and drinking as the court-martial began Monday _ “has made some really bad judgment calls, and you’re going to see that he’s admitted to them.”
Christensen also said the jury would have to think as the soldiers were thinking.
“The whole case is about getting inside their heads, not just Spielman but everyone he is accused of conspiring with,” Christensen said. “We have to feel the things they felt if we are do our job.”
Spielman’s attorneys, who have argued that he had no prior knowledge of the attack, have filed a motion to dismiss the charges against him unless the military grants Army psychiatrist Lt. Col. Elizabeth Bowler immunity to testify.
Christensen said that Bowler’s testimony would be a critical component in arguing whether Spielman participated in a conspiracy.
“His mental state and the mental state of his co-conspirators is all relevant,” Christensen said.
Spielman’s attorneys have argued that questionable practices and undocumented distribution of medication to soldiers could have left them in a mental state in which they were unable to recognize both the nature of the crime or that there was any conspiracy to commit it.
Bowler was attached to Spielman’s unit and treated at least three of the soldiers charged in the attack. Through her attorneys, she has declined to testify unless she is granted immunity from prosecution.
The Justice Department last month declined her request for immunity, but the military authority overseeing the Army case has yet to issue a ruling on the request.
The judge said Tuesday that he would hear testimony about the relevance of Bowler’s testimony before ruling on the motion.
Two other soldiers charged in the attack have told investigators that Spielman, of Chambersburg, Pa., knew of the plan to rape the girl in Mahmoudiya, a village 20 miles south of Baghdad, and was present when they hammered out details over swigs on a bottle of Iraqi whiskey.
During their courts-martial, Spc. James P. Barker and Cortez testified they took turns raping the girl while Green shot and killed her mother, father and younger sister. Green shot Abeer Qassim al-Janabi in the head after raping her, they said. The girl’s body was then set on fire with kerosene to destroy the evidence, according to testimony and military documents.
Green has pleaded not guilty in federal court to charges including murder and sexual assault. No trial date has been set.
Barker, who pleaded guilty in November to rape and murder, said Spielman came to the home knowing of the plans. Pfc. Bryan L. Howard, who stayed at the checkpoint to monitor radios, testified during a hearing in March that he overheard Spielman and the others discuss the rape beforehand. Howard pleaded guilty to being an accessory to rape and murder. Cortez also pleaded guilty in the case.
