Lawyers describe strategy of defending Mary Winkler
From there, the so-called legal ‘dream team’ built their defense highlighting talk of abuse for the woman accused of killing her small-town Church of Christ minister husband, Farese said at a recent legal seminar as he offered insight into the team’s strategy.
‘We were pogo-sticking in a mine field,’ he said. ‘So we said our case was like the Charlie Rich song, ‘Behind Closed Doors,’ that no one knows what goes on behind closed doors.’
Winkler shot Matthew Winkler in the back with a 12-gauge shotgun while he was in bed in their home. She was initially charged with first-degree murder, but was convicted in April of voluntary manslaughter, a much lesser offense.
She was sentenced in June to three years, and spent 12 days in jail in addition to five months of previous time served. A judge has allowed her to serve the remaining 55 days before she is eligible for parole at a mental health facility.
Farese and Ballin have given about a dozen presentations to Memphis-area legal groups on the case since it concluded, discussing witness preparation, theme development, dealing with the media, and placement of evidence.
One part of their strategy was illustrating the abuse Winkler claimed she received from her husband. During the trial, Farese asked her to identify a white platform shoe she said Matthew Winkler made her wear with a miniskirt and black wig to act out a sexual fantasy of his.
Winkler momentarily held the shoe, which was taken from the closet at the couple’s home, and then placed it on the railing of the witness stand just a few feet from jurors, who could not look at her without also seeing the shoe. It remained there during most of her testimony.
‘That didn’t just happen,’ Farese told a group of about 70 lawyers, judges and students. ‘We told her ‘Until the judge tells you to take it down, you leave it there.’ The prosecution never objected.’
Ballin said the attorneys used a private investigator to survey attitude in Selmer toward their client. The investigator’s findings convinced them no change of trial venue was needed.
Farese said he believed the case would turn on how well Winkler told her story to the jury and said he and Ballin told her she needed to go back to the way she was at the time of the shooting.
On the stand, Winkler was soft-spoken and kept head down and a forlorn expression on her face as she told jurors that her husband had been physically, mentally and sexually abusive to her during their 10-year marriage.
‘She went from being Mary of April 2007 to Mary of March 2006,’ Farese said. ‘You can call it coaching or prompting, but I call it trial strategy.’
