Good looks can go a long way
Don’t tell me looks and gender aren’t important when we have a teacher in Spencer going to prison for 15 years for the same thing former model/teacher Pam Rogers did and got just 198 days behind bars ‘ that is, until she blew her big break.
Van Buren County High School teacher Johnny McElroy, 55, entered a guilty plea to charges of sexual battery by an authority figure and statutory rape Monday (the exact charges Rogers entered a no contest plea to) and received the 15-year sentence, proving what’s good for the goose isn’t also good for the gander when it comes to the law.
People can talk all they want about these cases being different but we’re stuck with a set of facts which are very similar with the only big difference being one offender was male and average looking, and the other was female and gorgeous. If anything, the Rogers case was a little worse as far as the crime is concerned.
First off, Rogers’ victim was 13, just barely above the line set by the law for children 12 and under where she would have faced child rape charges and a mandatory 15 to 25 years in prison with no chance of early release. The victim in the McElroy case was 15 for most of the affair and in high school.
Both of the teachers used the schools for their illegal sexual meetings, Rogers meeting her young boy at Centertown Elementary, yes, elementary, and McElroy at Van Buren County High. And, both had trysts during class trips and at places outside school. However, Rogers went a little beyond that of McElroy, bringing the boy into the sanctity of her own marital home and then going to the victim’s home.
I’m not defending either of these folks. All I’m saying is that, at minimum, the Rogers case was at least as bad as the McElroy case but the amount of justice heaped on the older male was much harsher.
Now, before you start saying it was prosecutors or judges let me just remind you that the reason Rogers was settled for a fraction of what McElroy got was the realistic expectation that a jury of 12 would not send up a blonde bombshell for having sex with a boy. I severely doubt Rogers would have gotten anything over statutory rape (one to two years) in a negotiated verdict pitting jurors who felt she was a hebephile against those who secretly envied the youth.
So, when you break it down it’s society which is responsible as we hang doggedly to our old sexual stereotypes, winking and nodding when it involves a good-looking woman but coming with lynch-mob mentality and torches when it’s a man and a young girl. The Rogers counsel knew they had bargaining room while the McElroy advisors knew the writing was on the wall.
In the end, the two may end up serving about the same amount of time given Rogers’ inability to abide by her cakewalk probation terms which have landed her behind bars for the remainder of her eight-year sentence, plus two additional years for sending the boy her famous cellphone video. However, I think we all know Rogers was treated much easier because she was a good-looking female. Unfortunately for her, she was also a weak-willed woman who was living in a dream world, which has become a jail cell for the foreseeable future.
But then, why should I be surprised in a society which gives a woman seven days in jail for shooting a sleeping man in the back? Maybe we can have all of them come back sometime to grand marshal our Christmas parade.
Duane Sherrill is a reporter for the Standard. He can be reached at 473-2191 or by e-mail at [email protected].
